Great choice for on-the-go breakfast. They offer breakfast bagel sandwiches as well as simple bagels with cream cheese. I ordered the Queen City (egg, goetta, and American cheese) and I thought it was delicious. My husband customized his and made his own creation that he also enjoyed. Prices are very reasonable.

Favorite place for bagels in cincy! Love the rosemary bagel

Good price, we tried 3 different sandwiches, and took half a dozen back home with us. So much better than store bought bagels! Would highly recommend 👌

I LOVE bagels. Every time I visit NYC, I travel a whole hour by subway to visit my favorite bagel shop.So when I found this place in Cincinnati, I got really excited. I live just a few blocks from here, so I visit multiple times each week.Outstanding bagels, handmade fresh daily.

Very good bagels very good sandwiches and excellent service will definitely be returning

This place is fantastic! Ive been meaning to go for a while and finally had the chance. I took my three toddlers there. Each one ordered a bagel with cream cheese and LOVED them. I had the Vegan Smoked Cheddar spread and it was phenomenal--as was the rosemary bagel I had. The bagel itself was soft and honestly just perfect texture wise. All the kids had chocolate chip cookies which were a hit! Im definitely returning. I was able to get drinks for the kids too. We went to Washington Square to eat which is a SHORT walk (even a three year old can do it with minimal whimpers). Staff was great, friendly, and the place was super clean.

Great place in the Over the Rhine neighborhood for a quick bagel breakfast made your way. Similar concept to Subway, but for bagels. Pick your type of bagel, your spread, eggs if you want, meat if you want, cheese if you want. Made fresh daily. Service is fast. Generally for take out - only a few seats.

We have been three times since moving into the neighborhood and each experience is always top notch. The bagels taste great and they definitely dont skimp on toppings. The southwestern is my personal favorite and build your own is a great option for those who dont want any of the preselected options.

Wow! Grace and will were so helpful. Will walked me across the street and Grace spoon fed me cream cheese. 9/10

Been ordering through doordash for a while now but just wanted to reveiw well as a thanks for all the wonderful food, the best place to order for breakfast. Always makes my day great! :)

I’ve been searching for a good bagel in Cincinnati for a while now and finally found it! You definitely need to try the Bagelry if you want a great bagel!

We spent the weekend in Cincinnati for my husband’s birthday. Decided to have breakfast here because of the reviews, and trust me, no review will do justice. I’m not a fan of bagels, but I certainly would have breakfast here EVERY SINGLE DAY. I had the bacon avocado sandwich on a sesame bagel, and I cannot tell you enough how delicious it was. Owners and staff are extremely friendly and even listen to customer’s suggestions! My husband used to work at bagel stores a long time ago, and he was just giving them ideas for new bagels, which they paid attention to. I have a dozen bagels in my car going home for the next weeks breakfast and definitely will come back next time I come to the Queen City. Sesame bagels are my favorite. 🤤 🤤 🤤

Great customer service and delicious bagels. The everything bagel has the seasoning on both sides which is hard to find. I will definitely be back.

Great bagels and location. I would highly recommend them

I pre-ordered a dozen bagels to-go, with cream cheese and a container of coffee. They had it ready to go and were super friendly. The bagels are perfect-- the right amount of crunch, and the cream cheeses are delicious. This is a great little place for bagels, Ill definitely be back.Street parking available for a small fee. Located near the heart of otr, plenty of shops and restaurants a short walk away.

Ok...bagels have little flavor and meats heated in microwave as well as eggs...ewww and 10 bucks a sandwich??? Should be made on a grill

Best bagel around. Closes to NY Ive found.

Really delicious sandwiches! The avocado toast bagel was wonderful. Highly recommend!

The bagel is very good, but I placed an online to go order at 11:21 for two bagels to “skip the line” and they gave me a 10 minute wait time. Multiple people ordered after me once I arrived to pick it up and then got their order before me. I ended up getting my to go order at 12:02.

GRACE AND WILL ARE AWESOME GIVE THEM A RAISE!!!!!

Excellent bagels. Try any avocado breakfast sandwich. Really appreciate quick friendly service here.

The roasted veggie cream cheese is the best cream cheese Ive ever had

Solid menu, solid service. Bagels are light, really good coffee.

Very pleased with the food and service I have received

My bagel was ok. It just made me want to go to Marx Bagels which is so much better.

I love this place! They have great bagels and friendly service. You have to try a bagel breakfast sandwich! They are made fast and are so delicious.

Was surprised they were open on Saturday, did not have the full line up of bagels. But what I had was the everything bagel, with bacon and scallion cream cheese. The bagel was delicious and the cream cheese was outstanding

Love the Bagelry! Their bagels are amazing and we especially love the build your own bagel sandwiches. Im always wary with breakfast sandwiches with that kind of egg youre getting, Im a little picky with my eggs, but eggs from the Bagelry have always been real eggs, fresh, and delicious, like everything else.Theyre doing great with taking precautions due to COVID. Recently placed a pick up order, super easy, took literally less than a minute to hop out of the car, grab my order, and hop back in. I know my food sat a little bit from when I ordered(had to drive down), but it was still warm, fresh, and tasty. Definitely a great place to grab takeout from or delivery, dont let the lack of in person ordering deter you. Staff have always been super friendly and helpful. Little pricey, but definitely worth it for a small business.

Phenomenal bagel - 10/10Great service alsoNot like doughy bagels found at the super market - thin and flavorful which remind of Montreal style.

Unless youve been to New York this will be the best bagel youve ever had.

Ugh Im so torn. I tried this place for the first time today and it was DELICIOUS! Im from CT so a good NY bagel is everything and this does not disappoint. So naturally I go to their website so I can order breakfast for my team and find that everything is MUCH cheaper than what I paid though Uber Eats this morning. I was wondering why my breakfast sandwich cost $8.50 and my regular coffee $3.75, but I figured I was paying for freshness. Nope! Now I feel hopped 🙃

LOVE this place! One of the best breakfast sandwiches in Cincinnati by far. Whenever I need something quick in the morning, I pop in here and grab a bacon egg cheese sandwich on an everything flavored bagel. The best part about their everything bagel is that it’s coated with the seasonings on both sides. So delicious. Absolutely check this place out.

Best bagels in town and excellent service. Had a breakfast sandwich that was crazy good

Best Bagels in the city

Awesome bagels!! Best in Cincinnati.

Best bagel shop in Cincinnati! Options are limited in the city (Ive never understood why!) - and this place is a dream come true. I love a classic bagel smothered in cream cheese, but they also have great egg sandwiches... yum! Service is always speedy, even on the busiest days.

Great bagel combinations especially the smoked salmon bagel. The staff is very friendly as well.

Great bagels! I wonder where they source the flour and what the quality is, I do not see that mentioned anywhere, or the integrity of the ingredients at all. 4 stars for taste. Please keep the “everything” bagels separate from the others, garlic and onion do not mix with blueberry for example in the same bag...

I keep going back because its so good. Its like their bagels dont have a bottom side because both sides are round and covered in whatever delicious toppings you prefer. Im a big fan of the everything bagel with the vegan smoky cheddar spread. Delicious!

Hottest new joint in all of Cincy!!

Best bagels in Cincinnati. Lox on everything makes a great lunch!

Loved their bagels since the first time I had them at a pop up. Delicious real deal bagels and delicious cream cheese options. My favorite is the bacon scallion. Today I have a egg and sausage bagel (with a salt bagel!) and it was delicious. So happy they finally opened a store front!

I have had ate from their establishment several times now and had have not been disappointed. It can get busy and there is limited seating however staff and ambiance of establishment is welcoming and friendly. The menu can be a bit pricey but theyre so good I dont care. Who can argue with fresh made daily in house bagels? Plus, they have vegan and vegetarian options which is great. Their Brown butter chocolate chip cookie is AMAZING. I enjoyed their Lox sandwich on Salt bagel. A great place to grab a quick breakfast or lunch!

Great bagels.!. if you havent been your seriously missing out. Fun sandwich options great bulk price for the quality. Also jalapeno garlic cream cheese is great with everything or salt bagel.

Great fresh bagels!

Great place for a killer bagel. I got the turkey club and it was fantastic. They clearly care about their food. Its super good and quick. Would bagel again.

Hands-down the best bagel sandwiches in town! Plus the service is exceptional! If you haven’t tried it, then you are missing out!

Love their vegan cream cheese! Absolutely to die for. Ive had a couple less than positive customer service experiences, but I keep going back for the cream cheese. 😆

Fresh and tasty bagels in Over The Rhein. The staff is friendly, too!

Good bagels, nice cream cheese selection, but nothing to make it stand out from others. Its signs are cute, though

Awesome bagels! The staff is always super nice. Get there early to have the best selection of bagels!

Amazing bagels, worth the drive if you don’t live in OTR. Best bagels in the city hands down and their cream cheese is amazing as well. Love this place and everything they offer, can not recommend this bagel shop enough.

The lox are flown in fresh and it tastes like it! The bagels are perfect...a bit crunchy on the outside and soft and warm on the inside, with just the right number of air bubbles coming through the crust. The research behind what has resulted in one of the best bagels ive tasted is obvious. These things are made with love and science for sure. Not only that, the eggs on the breakfast bagels are cracked by hand....no eggs poured from a carton in this place. Im so glad we have a real bagel store in the city...finally.

My favorite bagels!!! I get them a dozen at a time and keep them in the freezer. Then pop them in a hot oven to heat up and theyre perfection!!! Soft and chewy inside and crispy outside. Smear of cream cheese or butter and its heaven.

Go every thurs morning. very little wait and always get my order correct. 100/5

GOOD FRESH BAGELS!

I like this place .. food is excellent .. service is super .. quick & clean.I recommend it .. u wont be sorry to give it a try.

Every one seems to love it and it always smells great when Im picking up orders for Uber Eats

Always one of my favs! Top service always!

Just giving them a try today and wow.. impressed by their bagel. Ordered the sriracha avo bagel. It was delicious. It feels criminal to say, but better than Brueggers. Will be back.

Bagels are excellent. Everything bagels are covered on both sides and the garlic and jalapeño cream cheese is great. Staff is nice and the restaurant is clean. Very nice spot in Cincinnati.

Arguably the best bagels in Cincinnati. Good coffee, good atmosphere. Great people!

Hidden gem. My new go to bagel place. Highly recommend.

Didnt want to hire me for obvious reasons (though I accepted a job somewhere else), but their food looks good from what I saw. Might try it one day.

Perfect way to start your day!

A morning stop a few days a week great staff good food choices

Great prices and delicious with lots of options,will be back for sure! They could add a couple of extra bar stools though, had to stand to eat.

Delicious! I cant wait to go back.

I got there late on Saturday so there were only slim pickins left...BUT there are fantabulous!!!! Next get there early 🤦

Unbeatable bagels, amazing staff, and amazing owners. I love this place.

Was just grabbin a Bagel to go and catchin my bus right out front... Excellent Cinnamon Raisin with cream cheese! Very fast and friendly service!Support your Local Bagelry Cincinnati!! 💗

Bagels are fresh and delicious. Definitely will come back

Great bagels from a locally owned company. And they not only have cold brew coffee, but nitro cold brew!

NYC bagels without leaving Cincinnati

Great bagels, great prices, great people. Worth the 14 blocks I have to walk to get one in the morning.

Cute decor, amazing bagels and nitro cold brew coffee. Amazing vegan options including herbed cream cheese and smoked cheddar nut cheese.

The Pizza Bagel is amazing!! Highly Recommend.

They make really friggen good bagles, better than any of the chain places by far

Ordered food for a breakfast meeting at the office, they were very responsive to the catering email, ready at the appropriate time, extremely friendly on pick-up, and had some delicious bagels and sandwiches! Will be coming back to try out some of their lunch sandwiches!

Ive been generally disappointed with breakfast sandwiches in Cincinnati, but this place has it. Fresh, no-nonsense bagel sandwiches.

It was only a matter of time before OTR had a great bagel place and it has finally arrived. The Bagelry offers a wide selection of delicious bagels in a super convenient location. My current favorite bagel combo is the asiago bagel with their bacon spread, it is delicious. Their pizza bagels and lox are pretty amazing as well. They also have drip coffee from Urbana Cafe and they have just added nitro cold brew as well. This is definitely a great place to grab some bagels or a sandwich for lunch! I always look forward to coming here!

The bagels have just the right texture, the spreads are an ideal complement.

Recommend the Italian sandwich!

Great addition to the Over the Rhine community

Good bagels

First time stopping in and I will be back! Great service and awesome bagels.

This is a very nice place and great eats

Im so excited for OTR to get a bagel shop!The Bagelry soft opened today at their first brick & mortar location which is at 14th & Walnut in OTR. The grand opening is Friday October 5th and then theyll be open 7 days a week. Id had their bagels a few times at Findlay Market and Second Sunday, so I was excited to check it out.I ordered the bacon, egg & cheddar bagel sandwich on a pumpkin spice bagel (cause basic is life). Overall it was great. The eggs were fluffy and the bacon was crisp. The only change Id suggest to the bagel sandwich itself is to add a bit of cream cheese.They also have local coffee available from Urbana Cafe!The ordering and pick up experience was pretty smooth and very fast. I was in and out in 5 minutes, and they have a standing bar around the windows if you want to stay and eat. I definitely encourage you to come by and check it out.

Best bagel in the country!

Good local bagel shop.

Only come here if you want to spend 20 dollars on two beagle breakfast sandwiches which really are nothing special. Rip off.

Delicious food and friendly staff

Favorite spot for my breakfast bagel

Loved the vegan salad!

Amazing New York style bagels

Love this place and not too pricey!!!!@

Hands down the best bagels in Cincinnati!

Great friendly service

Bagels and coffee are delicious!

Great service and people