Pie had perfect amount of cheese and sauce. Sauce was delicious. Crust was very crunchy, zero flop. They had a grandma pie on display that looked mouthwatering. Well be trying that next.

We ordered from Johnnys to try a different pizza place in the area. We used the Slice app to order a 20 cheese pizza and 6 garlic knots. We were quoted 35-50 minutes for our delivery to arrive. The order arrived within the quoted time! Score! The delivery guy was friendly, personable, and handled the food with care.The pizza was very good! It was piping hot, and had the right amount of sauce and cheese. The garlic rolls were good and flavorful, but could have used more oil, as they were a bit on the dry side.Overall, this is a good pizza shop! The prices are fair, its easy to order online, the delivery guy was nice, and the food was good. Ill definitely order from this place again!

Really tasty, perfect crust, great cheese. I recommend

Hidden gem! Ordered the grandma pizza, wings and the garlic nots and it was AH-MAZING!! The staff was super friendly too when I picked it up. Definitely recommend Johnny Pies!

I started getting pizza for here and I am very picky about my pizza as any New Yorker is. This comes extremely close to what New York pizza is like. Also, have tried several different items from the menu and have NOT been disappointed Thank you for great food in the neighborhood. Love this pizzeria!!

Great pizzeria! its not the biggest but its probably one of the best places in Coconut Creek.

What a great experience on this little New York pizza style. You definitely feel like you’re in New York. Pies are incredible delicious and toppings are ridiculously creative. It’s worth a visit. 5 stars for you guys!

This place truly has the BEST pizza and customer service in town!

Delicious, fast and staff very friendly and efficient, love it

Great service and amazing food.The BEST SAUCE!

Haven’t tried the pizza yet I just ordered delivery but the man who took my order over the phone was so nice he deserves 5 stars I’m hoping the pizza is also 5 starsI’ve been looking for authentic NY style pizza here in south Florida and I’m hoping I found it

I’m giving a 5 for the pizza and a 3 for everything else we ordered. The pizza is a true NY pizza. The dough, sauce and cheese were perfect. I didn’t need to add oregano or garlic powder so that’s a plus. However, the wings were soggy despite me ordering them extra crispy with buffalo sauce. I asked for ranch and blue cheese but there was no dressing in the bag. 🥲It’s prime dinner time and maybe they were busy but whoever took my order on the phone was so dull and clearly over it. I mentioned it was the first time we were ordering and her tone of voice/demeanor didn’t change at all. It seemed like she would rather get her fingernails pulled than to answer the phone. I get it, I worked retail for 20 yrs before starting my own business. It’s just tough because first impressions DO count.I have been loyal to Amici’s since moving to Coconut Creek last year because they went above and beyond when they didn’t have to. I do have to add oregano to my pizza, but I don’t mind because I look forward to the hand-written notes thanking me for my business. It makes a difference folks. I have learned so much from this experience. Someone may have a better product than you but it’s that little something extra added that keeps people coming back! Personality, hospitality, manners and a quality product goes a long way!

Ordered a large pizza it and a grandma slice, the pizza was ok but the grandma slice was probably the best pizza I every had. The sauce was everything. 🙌🏾🙌🏾

One of the best and most authentic NY style pizzas I have had south of Philly, especially in Florida.. A must try... what a good pie

As soon as i walked in i felt so welcomed by everyone who worked there! The pizza was amazing and i loved the atmosphere. 5 stars for you guys!

I ordered NY white pizza and wings last night and it was very delicious. My kids loved it and they usually only like cheese or pepperoni. The buffalo wings were well done as I requested and all the ingredients tasted so fresh. I will definitely be ordering from here from now on.

Johnny Pies is a pleasant jewel serving up old fashioned pizza at reasonable prices. We ordered the Silician Pizza with veggies, and what a treat. The flavors were absolutely amazing, with fresha toppings including bell peppers, diced tomatoes, mushrooms, black olives, and onions. I just love a hot served pizza with the ease of melted mozzarella cheese... And this didnt disappoint. Also, the Garlic Parmesan wings (18 CT) was delicious, and well cooked, flavored, juicy, and of adequate size and proportions. Dennis and the crew were amazing, great service, and welcoming friendly environment. Will definitely add to my favorite spots to dine in. Thanks Johnny Pies for a great first time experience.

This is a great neighborhood place. Dennis treats everyone like family. One night when I got off work late, he stayed open an extra 30 minutes to allow me to eat. Now that’s Italian!

I ordered a calzone from here because they are the best. There was some trouble with the computer system between postmates & the restaurant. I called after about an hour & 1/2 and I spoke to Dennis who apologized and quickly fixed the situation and had my dinner delivered (even after they were closed). The delivery guy was polite & continued to apologize for the delay. Class act people, and the food is always great! 👌 I will of course return. Thanks Dennis & team for taking care of me when I was hangry & tired from traveling all day!

We just moved here in February. Been searching for good 🍕 and good pasta, the gravey is on point.This place is legit, true NY flavor. They do it right.

I am so happy that Johnny pie is here in creek, as some said finally a good pizza place in the city which i 100% agree with. I have been in 4 times never been disappointed, fresh ingredients, fast and friendly service, very clean. the Spaghetti and garlic knots were delicious, pizza too.. Cant wait to go back

This place is just around the corner from us, and its amazing! Love having a slice before I head in to the grocery store next door. Always hits the spot!

Had to swing up here from Miami Beach for some errand. My boys had slices and a soda. They lived it. Very friendly and helpful service. Great slices.

Love their pizza. Very loyal to this place. Always quick and easy service. So glad they opened up near me

The pizza at Johnnys Pizzeria is the best we have had. Its tasty and it just like the New York pizza from years past.

Always fresh pies New York style!

Im living in Florida since 1997.Finally found Real New York Style pizza and everything else Ive ordered from them. Huge portions, Great Quality, and exceptional excellent people ...A+...

Delivery is extremely slow.. Dont matter if you live 1mile away ull still wait 1hr 30 -2hrs for delivery.

ONLY ORDER PIZZA from this place! I ordered hot wings that were so dry I dont even know if they put any sauce on them. Also, they were cold. I ordered the Italian wedding soup, and OMG they gave me cheap ziti mixed with chunks of mystery meat! The Italian sub was mediocre at best as well. Publix subs are 100 times better for half the price. I will give them credit on their pizza though. They have amazing pizza. I guess thats why theyre called Johnny Pies... LoL... I dont ever write reviews, but my wife and I were so disappointed that I had to. I should get a free cheese pizza at least for my constant business and disappointing order. Thanks.

I have stopped in several weeks and had a piece of the square pizza. It was delicious and I decided tonight to get some sides of meatballs, because I wanted to prepare a quick meal for my family and did not want to make the meatballs myself. I have to say the meatballs were just delicious! Really good. I will be going back in ordering them in the future. It’s really nice to have a local place where I can go pick up stuff that I know it’s gonna be delicious delicious. I look forward to ordering other items on the menu.

My favorite pizza spot in south Florida! Cupped pepperoni is how I knew it would be good. Pizza is on point!!! True up North style pies. Wings are really good too!

Tasty! I ordered two 20 specialty pizzas. A Garden of Vegan -- and a NY White.I didnt even think about the Vegan one having no cheese... I just wanted lots of vegetables for my wife. It was great!The NY white was loaded with chees and goodness! VERY good also.The gentleman who delivered was very friendly and genuinely nice to my son who took the order from him.I look forward to ordering from here again!

I don’t know what these people put on the pizza but it’s amazing!! I’ve had the stromboli, the gluten free, the Grandma, all of them are delicious. Every time it’s a good one. Hats off!

They make the best food and there sauce is amazing 👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽Also the staff is super friendly.

G reat neighborhood pizza p lace great people great service great pizza!

First time here. Hands down the best pizza !!

My wife and I ordered a Sunday gravy and Caesar salad. The ordered arrived on time but, the Caesar dressing was missing, which is essential for a Caesar salad. We called and the gentleman who answered asked me “what do you want me to do about it?” After a $40 tab, and a 2 min drive to our house, I think this question was unnecessary. This is not first time that our “delivered” order has been either cold, or missing an item. We understand mistakes happen but given that Bella Roma and Maninos are nearby, they need to be more conscentious.

The term NY pizza is often overused and especially in South Florida. I have traveled the world and in the least likly of places like a TIKI hut in Hawaii it will say NY pizza. As if NY pizza is now a worldwide brand. So after reading great reviews I gave it a shot. I ordered the Giant 18 inch pie which was a very reasonable $18.00. That is the same or similar price of a regular pie in the area. This was excellent. Perfect in every way. Since they also make other types of pies like Margherita pizza I will try that the next time. Friendly guys working there. If you order online just go straight there to pick it up as the online system may show a longer time to make the order than needed.

Great place brings the Big City to Coconut Creek. Pizza is very good.

I’m from NJ but have lived in FL the past 24 years. Not only was the pizza AMAZING, the owners and employees are as well. Best pizza around!

A frequent hangout of mine... Delicious food and cool guys.I strongly reccommend it.Tell them Matty Ice sent ya!

I have ordered from this place a few times and it’s always so good and the people are so nice. Today my family and I decided to order through UberEats, no problem right, wrong. The arrival window was between 6:45-7:10, I called the restaurant at 7:10 he told me he’d be there in a few minutes he was on the way, I waited until 7:35 and the person on the other end told me he was trying to get in touch with the driver, put me on hold and then tells me he’s having car trouble, but he would be there in 20 minutes. He could have told me when I called earlier. This to me means the order never left the store and they were going to make it. This business uses their own delivery drivers not Uber drivers. I never got my food a d was charged, he told me he couldn’t refund me I had to get in touch with UberEats. I will never again order for delivery and will have to think twice before even going there again. It’s a shame because the food is good.

The bolognese was awful. The girl who answered the phone asked my name 5 times, asked if the order was pick up or delivery 5 times. Waited on hold for 10 minutes. Just not worth the money, I expected better.

First time trying this Pizzeria.We ordered a 16’’ meat lovers and added ricotta cheese.The pie probably weighed 5 pounds!All the meats were of good quality, sauce was excellent, and they didn’t skimp on our extra topping.We will definitely be back!Thank you for an amazing lunch(and dinner and breakfast)!

Great pizza place! The dough is fantastic as well very good quality of ingredients. The staff is welcoming and happy to help. The garlic rolls are just perfect, not to garlicky, not too oily or burned. Just perfect. I lived in Italy and I love a good pizza and this is my place to go from all pizzerias in Florida!

I like it here, great food & service. Had a friend come into town and asked me to take him here again. Makes me feel like I am back in Tucson.

Excellent NY style pizza and environment. Will definitely be back soon.

Friendly people. Take out was ready when I arrived. For me pizza was average, but I know many folks love their pizza. Thats why I tried them, many good reviews. But wont be returning.

I live and work for the city and I have to say that this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Their Grandma’s pie is absolutely phenomenal and every other pie I’ve had from them is great. They are decently priced and very clean. I can’t wait to try everything else they have as well.Delivery is also very fast and staff is friendly!

Absolutely Delicious! Absolutely! Service with a smile. Good deals. Good prices.

First time trying this pizzeria since it opened and it was a pleasant experience. Decided to go for the 20 inch pizza, with each half of the pizza made with different toppings. Thank you so much for making my experience pleasurable and the pizza was delicious.

Getting busyHope they keep the spectacular tasting and great pricing on their pies!

Seriously fresh food using quality ingredients.In a very short time, I ❤️ Johnny Pies. The restaurant is very clean (as is the open kitchen), the staff is friendly and accommodating, and the pizza is delicious. I was a regular patron elsewhere, but over time the quality deteriorated to inedible and I’d given up on good NY style pizza in this area. I’m SO happy to have found this place. Give it a try. You won’t regret it.

Best pizza. Reminds me of the pizza joints I grew up with in the Bronx. Thin crust. Sausage and onions pizza is amazing. Top notch pepperoni and the sauce is perfect. Nice clean place with friendly owners.

First time we ordered was last night. It was great. They even went out of their way to prepare my meal to avoid my dietary restrictions. Price was great, food was great, delivery was quick, and well definitely be regulars now.

Its my second time here and I absolutely love the customer service I receive and the food is excellent.

Very good pizza

Need to update google menu prices. Entrees have increased about $5.

Great place to spend with family. The staff are excellent and deliver the best customer service possible. The food is absolutely excellent and cooked to perfection. Also Dennis Mannarino should win employee of the month for his tremendous dedication to the restaurant, and how he handles everything perfectly.

Amazing and delicious pizza and rice balls! Along with great and fast customer service, and the kindest staff, especially Dennis.

I have been here 5 times, never disappointed, the food is fresh and very tasty, price is reasonable.Open kitchen which is very clean, the whole place is. Very convenient located, with plenty of parking. Service with a smile

Pizza just ok.

1st here. Had the lunch 2 slice special. Great pie. Definitely will be back.

This is some of the best pizza I have ever had!! This Pizzeria also supports local school programs!! So amazing.

Honestly some of the best pizza Ive had in Florida. Ive had dozens of places in florida and nothing honestly comes close. The pizza tastes so fresh, and their own brand soda is very tasty as well. This place is a must try is you want a tasty quick and cheap bite.

Havent had anything like this before in Broward. REAL New York style. They offer Sicilian and grandma style as well along with other Italian dishes

This pizza is amazing! My husband and I order it every Friday night.

Best pizza in the area!!! I would definitely recommend eating here not only because of the delicious fresh food but the amazing service.

Great ingredients and sauce on the pizza.

Great service, very friendly, delicious food. Highly recommend this pizzeria - 5 stars!!!!1

My husband and I stopped in and shared two slices and a soda it was the best pizza weve eaten in a very long time and definitely New York style. A while later we had talked about what we were going to do for dinner and we decided to go back to Johnny pies and have dinner there. It was so delicious and affordable. This place just cant be beat and we will be eating there more often

Ordered a large half-anchovie/cheese pizza, 6 buffalo wings and 6 Italian wings. Was told I should expect the delivery within 45 minutes. I thought if anything it might come a little early because its literally a 2 minute drive from where I live.The food arrived an hour later. The Italian wings looked amazing, smothered with garlic and different seasonings. Thats why I was so shocked to discover that they were incredibly bland and dry. It was as if they were cooked, refrigerated for a couple nights, and then microwaved. Gross.The pizza was decent tasting, though cold. Id be open to trying a couple of slices for take out at a later date, but only take out and only pizza.

Good pizza

The most authentic New York style pizza I’ve had in south Florida in a very long time! Haven’t tried anything aside from pizza or calzones but it is very delicious and kid approved! Super nice staff and owners

Their pizza is excellent. Todays Sicilian Pizza was exceptional.

Ive lived in Coconut Creek for 23 years now and Ive been waiting 23 years for a decent pizza place to come to this city. My wait was over today. What took you so long Johnny Pies?Id like post pictures of the aesthetically pleasing food, but unfortunately, Ive already eaten it.

The pizza slices were great. Good service, clean pot. I will definitely be coming back.

Best pizza in town. I go here after school and the waiting time is minimal and the service is good. The pizza is amazing and takes u back to Italy

The pizza was deliciousYou will experience NYC pizza here!

In one word delicious you can taste the quality definitely the only option in Coconut Creek.

Wonderful food, wonderful staff, great prices, clean and bright pizza place; and its way more than just pizza! I cant wait to visit again! I highly recommend this restaurant, and Im a picky eater!

The Grandma pie is delicious! Service is great, staff is warm and friendly.

Johnny Pies is a new Italian place that just opened in my neighborhood. They sell New York style pizza, wings, calzone, Strombolis, pasta. Italian dishes, salads, and hot subs. So far Ive tried the chicken Parmesan sub and the pizza and both were great.I know Im going to be eating here a lot because its right next door to the Publix. I was on my way in to get something to cook for dinner and decided it was just easier to get takeout. I see that happening a lot this summer. If you can make it in for lunch they have some great inexpensive lunch specials.The interior of the restaurant is bright and they have tables if you want to dine in. Everything is nice, new, and clean and everyone is friendly. I love Italian food so its great to have a new takeout option. Welcome to the neighborhood Johnnys!

Great PIZZA ♡♡♡ wonderful customer service and prices!

Amazing place. My daughter absolutely loves their pies and shes a picky eater.

Pizza was good wings are good

Pizza is good! Ive had it twice so far, its a thin crust italian pizza. I decided to order something else with my pizza yesterday, so I got a small pasta fagoil soup. The worst soup I ever had unfortunately!! Im sorry who ever made that soup 11/30 it was absolutely disgusting, I had one bite and threw it out

Johnny pies pizzeria is not only the best pizzeria New york style in Florida.! But its the best Slice you ever put in your mouth.!!!! OH and the entrees are amazing.!!!! Fa-get-a-bout-it.!!!!

Delicious. Very good service and kindhearted.

I dont know anything about the cashier on friday but the pizza is great, the pizza Florida really needed.

Really Great food at a good price!Ingredients are fresh and it comes out in the flavor of whatever you decide to eat from Johnny Pies.Its a shame that this establishment did not arrive in Coconut Creek sooner.

Just another pizza place. Nothing special. Good luck as several pizza places have been in that plaza over the decades. Ive been told by several pizza places that to duplicate the NY style of pizza, one must use theb water from NY.

Amazing food. Great staff, owner and service. Will be returning

Nice clean friendly place food was excellent

Johnny pies use good ingredients for a great northeast style pizza, although you cant get moms meatball there they come a close second.Try the stromboli.

Excellent customer service.. Nice tasting pizza!

Got a 16 meat lovers pizza for $17.99. It was a hit. Delicious.

Just ok pizza have not tried anything else yet. Food out on counter looks old. Very unappealing. Should keep it covered.

Great pizza (loved the broccoli rabe and sausage pie)! Chicken parmagiana sub delish too. Friendly service. Highly recommended!

Delicious! Great sauce. Great dough.