Awesome experience and offers are more than fair. Michael was courteous and efficient and knowledgeable. Would highly recommend if you value the perfect overall customer experience. Thx!

Great customer service! If you want to sell unwanted jewelry, you should go to Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry. (I am new to the area and looked online as most people do.)Steve was very patient, professional and caring. Giving great advice if you don’t know if you want to sell an item or not. He also takes the time and explains everything so you understand what your item is worth. Go there, you will not be sorry... they are honest and genuine.

Dominic was fantastic. Quick and gave me $ on the spot. Highest value I’ve gotten on my gold necklace- definitely won’t be going anywhere else! Highly recommend

I really enjoy coming into the Dublin location. Dom and I always have great conversation and he saves the items I collect for me to view whenever I am in the area. I highly recommend stopping in if you like coins!

Shop was great and easy to find! Lots of coins and paper money for collectors. Mike was fast and efficient with helping me and multiple customers at the same time. Would recommend this shop to anyone looking to buy or sell coins!

Very quick, professional & worth the visit. I was offered a very fair amount. I will definitely use again

Do not sell your jewelry anywhere else. Local high end jewelers quoted me half the value that Dominic paid me in cash. Great value, great service. Highly recommend this facility.

Mike was great helping me with my scrap gold and picking out a wedding gift. Highly recommend this shop for all of your gold and silver needs!

Fantastic place! Dom & Mike are always helpful and fair with me. Come visit these guys with your gold and silver jewelry.

Great shop for selling gold. Mike was very informative and paid us more than anyone else in town!

Pretty neat shop, my kids loved it! Lots of fun history to look in coins, Mike also helped us pick out some fathers day gifts! Great shop and good location of town. Thanks

Dom is an extremely knowledgeable and fair coin dealer. I always enjoy stopping in and he is extremely helpful when I want to buy or sell coins!

Mike and Dom are both very helpful. I highly recommend this location, especially if you are new to collecting gold and silver. Lots of great collectibles as well!

They were very informative. Dominic did not mind giving me guidance and information over the phone. They were very friendly. I will send my friends their way.

I stopped into Buckeye Gold today with an old class ring and was helped by Dominic. He was quick in determining authenticity and getting me an offer on this item. I shopped it around and Buckeye Golds offer was the highest out of the three places I visited, so there is no doubt Buckeye Gold is the best gold buyer in town!

The guys there are very professional and friendly. They are efficient and very knowledgeable and explain how the whole process works. I will definitely be going there again and highly recommend.

I have been coming to Buckeye Gold for years with Dental Gold and Dominic always does an efficient and fantastic job helping me out. He is very thorough when sorting the different purities and diligent when cleaning the crowns out. They are the best place to go with any unwanted Dental Gold.

Mike and Dom are great people to work with when buying and selling coins and jewelry. Highly recommended stopping in to see them!

Great place to shop. Mike and Dom are very helpful and easy to deal with. Very knowledgeable.

Super awesome place. The most honest people in the precious metal business that I have ever dealt with. Im blown away!

Customer service was terrible.They offered me pennies on the dollar for jewelry. They left me standing at the door for minutes. If you are selling jewelry dont come here.In response to your response. I rang the bell more than once and still was left waiting. From the beginning I felt like you didnt want my business. There is a way you can tell people what they dont want to hear without being condensending and that was not accomplished with my experience with your business. Thank you

I shopped around for the place to sell my old wedding rings in 2020 (I know, what fun) and Buckeye Gold on Sawmill Road gave me a much better offer than anywhere else I took them. They were fast, friendly, and knowledgeable. Id highly recommend.

Mike at the shop was very helpful and knowledgeable. He helped pick a gift out for my uncles birthday that was coming up. Neat store with lots of rare and cool coins!

Nov 2021. We went to Buckeye Gold on Sawmill to sell a silver coffee set and some other items. Dominic and Mike were very easy to talk to and told us their process to buy gold and silver. Very informative. We were given a very good offer, in our opinion, and walked out with some extra cash. You will not fell pressured to sell. Highly recommended.

Mike and Dom, are the best . They pay the most for your gold and diamonds.

Friendly and knowledgeable staff, excellent service!

We have recently been to both the Hilliard and Dublin locations and received excellent service both visits. Knowledgeable, friendly and encouraging to our young coin collector. Already looking forward to our next visit.

Great service; the guy took a lot of time introducing and explaining our interested kids to appropriate coins, and he was very honest and genuine.

They give good price for gold and silver

I went to Buckeye Gold Coin to see if they were able to examine a pendant to confirm the karats it was advertised as. Steve was extremely helpful and quickly was able to determine the karats of the piece and weight for me. Having been so helpful and thorough in explaining everything despite me not making a purchase, I tried to give him some money but he refused to accept it. Im super appreciative of Steves knowledge and willingness to help and I would without a doubt recommend his store to anyone.

This place is awesome for purchasing precious metals. Dominic and Mike have been a pleasure to work with, and I will definitely return in the future to do more business with them. I highly recommend this location if you’re looking to strengthen your position in hard assets, or if you just enjoy collecting gold and silver.

Awesome experience !! Super to work with, very informative and friendly ! I will be going back for sure ! Thanks for a great experience ! Highly recommend

Great service, fair price, no games or anything like that. Very knowledgeable, great place overall

We had a great experience with Dominic today. He help use with all of our needs. I would recommend any to go there that is selling gold or silver or in need of a nice piece of jewelry. Dominic Michael and Steve will take great care of you.

Stopped in for a last minute precious metal themed white elephant gift, without any knowledge of coins at all. Dominick instantly walked through a few options within our price range, and we made our way out with a fun, unique gift. Well be back!

Thank you Dominic! All my experiences have been enjoyable and I have recommended the Buckeye Gold store to friends who have also had a positive experience.I have worked with Dominic at the Sawmill Rd store a few times and can tell you he is a man of integrity and knows this industry extremely well. This is an excellent place to sell gold, silver, coins and estate jewelry. I have been satisfied with the payouts and they are quick, fair and knowledgeable. Yes.. I received more $ than a jewelry store down the street offered.

I went to several jewelers in town to sell some gold. I did not know those other jewelers were taking advantage of me until I went to Buckeye Jewelers! Dominic offered me top, fair market valve for my gold. The others quoted me hundreds of dollars less!! Dominic said they should have all offered me the same price as him because that’s the current market valve for the weight. Thanks again to Buckeye Gold and Dominic for running their business with integrity and professionalism. Those qualities will keep me coming back!! 👍

I came into Buckeye Gold in Dublin today as I am preparing to move. I was amazed at how much money some of the stuff I had was worth. Dominic did a great job helping me and explaining each step of the process. I without a doubt will recommend Buckeye Gold to any of my friends looking to sell and coins or jewelry!

Dominic did a wonderful job helping me sell some of my high karat jewelry. I would highly recommend Buckeye Gold for all your selling needs!

The young man who waited on me was courteous and patient. Not a whole lot of negotiations on price and not a lot of high end coins outside of gold, but a nice well kept store with good inventory. I will go back if I am ever in the Columbus area again.

I had a great experience with buckeye, Dominic was informative, friendly, and gave me a great price.

Dom is extremely knowledgeable and helpful. Always friendly and can find what Im looking for. He sees me coming and hell bring out selections of coins he knows Ill want before I ask. Always a fair price and I always walk away happy and with a new bit of numismatic trivia facts thats hard to find elsewhere.

I had been driving to the Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky area to get the best prices for my gold and jewelry. I had business nearby and brought some items to the Grove City store. Absolute top dollar offered and accepted. Mark, the store manager, is an outstanding professional; nothing doubtful about this operation. This will be a go-to resource for me. Thank you, Mark, for topping off a great day in the Columbus area!

Awesome place! Dominic is incredibly informative, fair, and friendly and the only one Ill ever bring my stuff to. Highly recommend both Dominic and Buckeye Gold!!!

Dominic was extremely helpful 🤗 He was able to assist me with questions I had on a couple of coins. Very well mannered and knowledgeable...highly recommend seeing him!!

Best experience one can have when looking for a fair and honest business. Most people frown at Jewelry stores; thinking that theyre going to rip them off somehow, such is not the case with Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry. Dominic was not only fair but extremely knowledgeable and helpful throughout the entire inspection and value of my items. I highly recommend Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry to anyone whom is seeking assistance with selling and/or purchasing from this establishment. If you want to SELL your personal valuables...Sell them to this honest establishment and NOT a pawn shop. You can rest assured that youve made the best decision and you wont be taken for a ride. Dominic, you were outstanding and Id like to thank you very much for your time and assistance! YOU ROCK!!!

Very pleased with my experience at the Graceland location, highly recommend! Educated professionals.

John King did a fabulous job at the Gahanna location!

Anthony was so helpful and patient throughout the whole process! Highly recommend working with him!

A true gem of a store. Everyone that works here is patient, remembers your preferences, and is fair in their pricing. Greg was particularly helpful in educating me on the basics of bullion investing. I have looked and looked and cannot find a better place in central Ohio to buy coins.

Dominic was extremely helpful and gave wonderful customer service! Helped me out a lot and gave me much better prices than any pawn shop I’ve ever been to!

Great experience! I met with Dominic to sell a gold chain and look at some of the rings in the store as well as the rare currency. Dominic was very knowledgable about every item i viewed. I would recommend him and buckeye gold to anyone.

Stopped in at Buckeye Gold in Dublin the other day and met with Dominic. He helped me pick out the perfect coin for a birthday present, which was great as I do not know much about rare coins. Very personable and knowledgable!

Great Experience, Dominic was extremely friendly, and knowlegable of the coins he was selling. I also bought my girlfriend ear rings for her birthday, and he took the time to package, and prepare then in a very presentable way. All around great service, and will be back for sure.

I have been to Buckeye Gold a couple of times, and have been extremely pleased every time. Dominic gave me great prices for my Pandora Charms & Bracelets and I would recommend seeing him and any of the great people who work at Buckeye Gold.

Anthony DiMuzio was really helpful and extremely professional! I will definitely be back to see him!

From the moment I walked in the door I had wonderful customer service. The owner was actually the gentlemen that helped me. He was training an employee at the time but they gave me great service and walked me through everything. Will be coming back and recommending them to everyone!

I had the pleasure of working with Steve Fagin. Steve is good vibes and seemed trustworthy and genuine. I would recommend Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry to anyone needing these services.

Wow! What a great experience! Stopped in to look at making a investment purchase, not only was Greg Hinaman helpful, but informative! The owner was actually there also, and brought out some items that had just arrived for my wife and I to look at! Will definitely go back! Thanks Buckeye Gold!

I would like to say the Dublin location is by far my favorite and Dominic at this location is very knowledgeable and easy to due business with. Highly suggest you go see him best place in Columbus to get coins or bullion and also cash in your unwanted coins and bullion.

I had a friendly and fast transaction. The gentleman was very nice and made me feel at ease. I will do all of my gold selling business here with great confidence.

I went in the store recently looking for some small pearl earrings. I spoke with Dominic who was very helpful and knowledgeable about the items i was interested in and was able to help me find exactly what i was looking for. I would recommend Dominic and Buckeye Gold to anyone.

Steve helped me make a lifelong dream come true. Hes a scholar and a gentleman. This business has my absolute endorsement.

I have been working with Steve and Lee at Buckeye Gold Company for quite some time, and have to say I would never go anywhere else! They are consistently willing to pay more than other places I have tried, and show you how they get to the total they give. I would recommend to all of my family and friends!!

We went in yesterday and were quoted by an employee, were told to check around and come back tomorrow and he would honor his quote. Needless to say that didnt happen. They offered over $100 less and refused to honor the price even after confirming what the previous gentleman had said. Be weary of this sketchy business.

Dominic is always willing to help and very personable

Steve Fagin is a GREAT guy, HONEST as the day is long. I have sold them coins and silver and every time has been a great experience. I cant recommend him and his company enough. DONT GET RIPPED OFF, GO TO BUCKEYE GOLD.

The young man that helped me was not nice or fair. He threw a few items back across the counter at me in a very disrespectful manner that were family heirlooms. Please don’t use this company or location.

Very nice and knowledgeable. 5 stars

Great deals.

They dont give u enough money

Fantastic

Very professional, thanks!

Dominic was a joy to work with, was very professional and extremely competitive in his pricing on my numismatic items. I would highly recommend Dominic & Buckeye Gold for any of your numismatic needs.

Will