Can you believe that this is what I received when I ordered a dozen gluten-free bagels? If I knew I was going to get seven packaged bagels from a famous bagel place I could have just gone to the grocery store.

Delicious bagels! Best in the Hamptons by far. Friendly staff. Lines look long but move extremely fast. Menu has a wide variety of sandwiches. Easy parking and a great location.

Not the friendliest staff, but we enjoyed the spicy hobo and regular hobo. Good coffee. Out of plain bagels, so we branched out and tried the garlic bagels and were glad of it. We both would have preferred some cream cheese to the hashbrown, but who are we to suggest a change to a staple? Napkins are the size and thickness of single-ply tissue. We made more of a mess trying to use them than if wed wiped our mouths on our sleeves.

Great place for breakfast. Best place for bagels!

If they knew how to cook a potato, this place would be perfect. Unfortunately, their hash browns and home fries arent even what I would call ok. But their omelettes, eggs and bagels are all top notch. And they do a great job with bacon too. I know it sounds like its easy to make bacon taste good, but theirs is top 10. Definitely a great spot to pick up breakfast to go.

Disorganized, rude, and never prepared to handle the morning rush. Why are there bagels on the floor? Better yet, why are there bagels on the floor next to a broom?

As good as bagels get and the sandwiches are delicious.

Was unable to place an order, even though I was right at the Deli counter. I was as patient as I could be, then had to walk out after every employee had looked at me at least once...2 stars because Ive been here before and decent bagels

Best bagels I’ve ever had! Flagels are great too. Amazing service.

Bagels are pretty good, but overall experience was rather poor.Was served by a young lady who seemed agitated/preoccupied. I asked for egg and cheese on one onion bagel and cream cheese, tomato, and onion on another onion bagel. I received egg and cheese on a salt bagel and onion and cream cheese on a second salt bagel. Unfortunately my order was to go and so I didn’t realize the errors until I opened the wrapping at home. What’s aggravating was that it was predictable, because I could tell the young woman was distracted. Frustrating experience, unfortunately.

Bagels and lox were good but counter staff not the warmest folk.

Horrible. The staff has no idea whats in the bagels. If u have an allergy or are vegan u need to know. Went to Montauk first for the vegan cream cheese and vegan sausage thats on the menu. Told they never have the sausage and sent us to East Hampton location. Also on the menu in East Hampton but they dont have it either. You really need to work on your customer service.

Despite some minor morning chaos and a seemingly visible staff shortage food was spectacular...

Was here for vacation and received a bagel with the wrong cream cheese and completely burnt/inedible. Wasnt worth it to drive all the way back for a bagel. Disappointing to say the least.

Awesome food and a great place to meet new people during the summer months!

The best. Usual bagel spreads plus pastrami and corned beef HUGE sandwiches

Customers are meant to feel like they are a necessary evil, rather than a valued part of the business.

Flagel was great. However, other stuff such as lox is very expensive. A small package is over $15, enough for maybe 3 bagels

Delicious fresh bagels

Just as good as any bagel from the city. It was crowded when we got there but their lines moved quick. This will be our go to breakfast spot when we visit MTK!

Bagels are not the best ive ever tried...pretty decent though

The best of the best in the Hampton’s.

Great bagels out east in the Hamptons area, they have multiple locations throughout the area so If breakfast or lunch is on your radar, find one and order you will not go wrong . Also as I always say all there Locations are super clean, and fresh bagel made throughout the day.

Food is excellent every time

The bagels are doughy and delicious. I also like the whitefish salad and baked salmon salad.

Their everything egg bagels are on point -- hits the sweet spot between a bagel and a pastry. Perfect with some scallion cream cheese + lox + lettuce + tomatoes + creamy onions + cucumbers + fresh squeezed lemon + small pinch of pepper.... delicious every single time.

This location in East Hampton run very well professional, great food, awesome selection, friendly staff

If you find the best stop looking for the rest

This bagel place is LIT. This is my second online review ever because it was so worth it! Bagel - lit, ice coffee - lit, Italian sub - lit. I’d spend the day there if i could.

Love the Goldberg famous bagel. The all kinds sandwich. Coffee delicious. The Hampton is beautiful.

These bagels are revolutionary, I would sell my soul for the everything bagels period

Call in your orderEverything FlagelsTip.

The absolute worst customer service. 3 out of 5 breakfast sandwiches were incorrect. When we called to speak about it the girl on the phone had a nasty attitude. When we showed up to get the correct sandwiches they full out screamed at me over the counter. I was an excellent customer of theirs and will never return. Shame on them for treating a paying customer that way.

The best bagel shop in town. Ive been eating here ever since I was able to chew solid foods. Consistency is key here. They make their own bagels and theyre always so fresh.

Excellent New York Bagels. Good breakfast sandwich friendly staff.

Bustling yet quick, robust menu for breakfast and lunch. Tasty bagels that compete with any place in NYC.

The people were very kind and the food was great.

Delicious bagels and cream cheese. Once staff started to take our order (it took a few minutes even at the front of the line to get attention), it was a good experience.

Food was excellent service was a little slow

Excellent service and and fresh food always

Service is slow. Seating is limited. Outdoor seating is next to the parking lot and you get whiffs of exhaust. Bagels are good but the other breakfast items are average.

This place is the worst.10:30am on a Sunday, line out the door. Waited 20 minutes to get one plain bagel to go. Asked for a coffee and told to go to the back of the other line and wait another 20 minutes.5:54am on a Tuesday, doors wide open, furniture set out, “open” sign clearly displayed, no one else but staff in the store, told I have to wait 6 minutes until I’ll be served. Seriously?? Just two examples of the regular bad experiences I have here.3 times out of 5 they’ll get your order wrong, zero sense of urgency, incredibly incompetent staff, very expensive for what it is.I get that it’s the hamptons but it’s so frustrating to see a business run this way and paying customers be taken advantage of so easily.Avoid.

Lines are crazy long on Saturday and Sundays. Staff manages reasonably well. Decent prices.

The best whole wheat everything flagels anywhere. Goldbergs seems to be the one place that doesnt skimp on toppings for bagels- plenty of seeds! Nice staff, and relaxed, laid-back atmosphere.

Best bagels anywhere.

Yes yes yes bagels are the best, hung over Sunday staple. Get the locks! Also the jalapeño cream cheese with grated cheddar is great pun intended, they have these squashed everything bagel that is super nice toasted.

Bagels and sandwiches were great!Lines were long and a little disorganized but moved quickly.

Fresh bagels and sandwiches. I recommend.

Goldbergs bagels is one of only a handful of traditional bagel shops serving freshly made bagels and prepared foods on eastern long island. The bagels themselves are delicious and add a schmear of one of their fresh selection of cream cheeses and your all set for breakfast. Expect the usual high Hamptons prices. The primary gripe I have with this place is the confusing nature of their ordering areas. After going here for many years I have learned the drill but newer customers walking in have no clue where to go so they always end up cutting in front of people who are already waiting in line. The owners need to look at this with a new eye and try to figure out a better flow.

When ordering a bacon egg and cheese, I expect a few pieces of bacon. Not ONE SLICE of bacon. Horrible service, then I call to speak to a manager, and no manager is working. Horrible customer service. GO TO THE ONE IN WAINSCOTT IT IS SO MUCH BETTER!

Well organized, good service and lots of tasty choices

One of the original Goldbergs bagel outlets. Located off the main road with the entrancearound back. Easy to miss if you address not careful.

Get the lox spread

Took 20 minutes to make a Beef Brisket Hero special. After complaining that I was still waiting for my sandwich, and the woman who took my order was making bagels for others, she produced a roast beef sandwich smeared with BBQ sauce in a couple of minutes. It was awful. This was the last time Im going here.

If you havent eaten here I highly recommend you dog so soon. The turkey pita melt sandwich is my favorite!

Expensive but quality...Love me a spicy hobo = bacon egg and cheese with hash brown on any bagel/bread

Egg everything bagel, scooped and toasted, with vegetable cream cheese..... mmmm mmmm mmmm

Garlic bagel with cream cheese and bacon was excellent

I went into the deli this morning I placed my order with a lady who did not understand the English language very well six people got served before me while I waited for a turkey and swish and an egg sandwich with egg whites I did not get egg whites I got runny eggs and my order was totally wrong and the home fries must have been in the deep fryer because they had no seasoning and I think the place was overpriced especially for the service you got

Good food options for a bagel shop. A little pricey.

Bagels are good. Not amazing, but they are pretty good.

Great bagels, fast service. But be prepared to cough up some big bucks, especially if you’re looking to buy anything non-bagel here

If you expect to get food and it taste the way you like? Dont go here!!!! Nothing taste right. Might be because its all kosher but the cream cheese taste funny, even when i got a chickenparm hero, the sauce tasted like they dump a pound of sugar in it. on top of that, They NEVER got my order correct once!!! Always need to send it back. Maybe the locals rave abouht it cause they are only used to Goldbergs and dont truly know what a good deli is or how much better the food can be. But not here.. Im a contractor, so i eat at atleast 3 different delis per week, Goldbergs is by far the worst Ive ever step foot in...

Great bagels and flagels, nice staff, relaxed unpretentious atmosphere.

Excellent sandwichesLong wait times to make sandwichesAnd better customer service.

Everything flagel, toasted, scallion cream cheese + coffee is a great start to the day.

Best bagels east of queens. Uncle Marty is a saint 🙌

Horrible

Why 4 stars? It would be 5, but once the employees learn what light, little bit, small spread or smear of cream cheese means.

Sooo good! The spicy hobo is delislcious 😊

Best NY bagels. Veggie cream cheese on everything bagel. Duh!

Great bagels. Fast friendly service.

Really good food, lines are long during summer weekends, but unlike most places in the Hamptons, its worth it here. No other bagel place east of the shinecock can compare.

Worth any wait. Great everything and toast to perfection.

Got a bagel one day with vegan cream cheese, bagel was burnt. Asked for home fries and got what are clearly mini french fries...nasty

The line is worth the wait

Good

Great food and service

Great food and staff!

Best bagels Ive ever had

Quite tasty bagels and spreads

Great bagels at a great price

Incredible coffee and bagel.

Best bagels in town.

Real NY bagels. Delish!

Love the service as much as the bagels.

Kitchen smoke all over

Bagels the way bagels should be. Authentic... period. Drop the microphone. nuff said.

The food is great.

Great selection of bagels.

Great bagles

Really good food

Best bagels !!!

The best bagels

Delicious sandwich 😁

The best!

Excellent breakfast but bit expensive

This Goldbergs has the beast bagels on Long Island!!!

Expensive but great breakfast sandwiches.

Sandwiches are great and fulling