Sam and Logan were incredibly helpful, knowledgeable, and trustworthy while assisting me with selling my dad’s coin collection after his passing. It’s clear they really love what they do and sincerely care about helping people. I highly recommend them.

WOW I was hesitant to go here for my coin needs. I easily made an appointment, they had exactly what I needed and so kind and patient! What a treasure ( pun intended). Great service Logan n Sam!

Sam and his associates we amazing. They respected my fathers collection, my sister and myself during a difficult time. Sam took the time to guide us through the appraisal process and educated us during they journey. Dont take my collection to a pawn shop, dad always said, and we didnt. Sam Shaffer is a true professional Numismatic with lots of knowledge! I highly recommend Sam and his team!

He had everything I was looking for and some more that I wasnt expecting, it was really easy getting rid of my Junk Jewelry with a reasonable offer and transaction. I recommend Sam 100%

Great place to sell your Collection, very Friendly knowledgeable and a pleasure to meet. Highly recommend seeing them.

I’ve known Sam for years and he’s the real deal. I’ve never had a bad experience with him.

Sam is very easy to deal with if your buying or selling currency. He always wants to give the best deals to insure continued business. Some places you take your currency too are quick to add it up and offer you a price. Sam researches and then offers you the best prices he can. He is very knowledgeable. I will definitely be back to do more business.

Cool guys! Very honest and knowledgeable. Bought my inherited coin collection for more than expected. Would definitely recommend 👌

I believe Sam to be a high integrity guy. While we all think our coins are worth more, and maybe they are, Sam offers a fair price, all things considered. I might have been able to get more, but by the time I go thru the hassle of posting, postage, fees, etc., I think Id net out about the same. You have to understand he has to make money too. And Im sure sometimes he loses. All in all, a great experience and believe I was dealt with professionally and ethically.

Sam is wonderful to work with!!! I have gone to him a few times now and really enjoy going to him with all my numismatic needs. I didn’t know what to expect the first time- if it’d be like Pawn Stars or what, but he sat down with me and took the time to go over everything piece by piece. He is very knowledgeable and intelligent and explained to me the reasons behind the different offerings he was making. I felt he was fair as well. He is easy going. He welcomed and answered any and all of my questions. I definitely recommend him to anyone.

Sam is super nice, explains what you have and is fair. I really enjoyed learning a little about the coins and had some things that we surprisingly valuable. Thanks Sam!

Sam and his staff are kind and professional. Great experience working with them as they are very knowledgeable in gold and silver bullion. Will definitely be going back to see them again!

Very knowledgeable, friendly and helpful.

Mr. Shafer is a Professional Numismatist with excellent knowledge. I purchased from him and I am very pleased. I will definitely purchase from him again.

I had the nicest and friendliest experience with Sam and his numismatics business. I was looking for sixpence coins - a tradition for weddings. He found two and even went to the trouble of providing display cases so they would look great when presented as special gifts! Plus he was willing to make it happen right away, Looking for coins that are unusual for events or collecting and want good customer service? Sams the one!

Beyond amazing!I had never contacted a coin delaer of this caliber before. Sam deserves every star out there and then some. I have gotten some of the best additions to my collection from here. Every time I get an order it is even better than the last one. Sam is an honest dealer and is definetly in the business out of passion for the hobby. I have gained huge amounts of knowledge from him over the past few months. Being a somewhat newer to the hobby having a dealer as good as Sam is amazing.

Sam was very helpful in doing an evaluation for me for insurance purposes.He was clearly knowledgeable, offered insightful and accurate explanations, and reflected a wealth of experience. I will definitely return to him if I have further questions or need for his services.

Today I sold a coin to Sam, and it was a very nice exchange. Hes very personable, knowledgeable and happy to educate. I enjoyed our discussion, and I highly recommend him.

See update below vvv This place has moved. I called to see where Sam may have moved to and it immediately went to voicemail. I verified this at the information desk and they told me to reach out to Sam directly. I should have called first.Update: Sam called me back an hour later. They have move to a new office building in Fishers. Unfortunately, I am unable to go there today to truly evaluate but will change from 1 to 5 stars. I don’t like to down-mark people while waiting for Google to update their information. Here are the directions to his new site:11 municipal driveSuite 200 (second floor)Fishers, IN 46308Hope this helps other.

Excellent place to bring your old coins! Sam has clearly found his passion in life, examining and learning the history of the various coins he shares with others. He actually even taught me how I could hunt for silver in coins from the bank! You can expect superior knowledge, attention, and fair treatment here.

Great service! Logan. Was very helpful and explained the whole process to us. We would definitely go back and would recommend.

I have had great dealings with Sam; an up and coming young Dealer and Numismatist he is very knowledgeable and easy to communicate with. I have purchased a couple of my most interesting additions to my collection from Sam and enjoy seeing his latest items- always well described and imaged. First rate!

Ive known Sam for several years now, and can attest to his honesty, competence and numismatic expertise. Hes simply the best. And I plan to buy more coins from him in just a few days. Hes dependable, honest, knowledgeable, and totally trustworthy.

Sam is a very skilled, professional and courteous business man. He goes out of his way for his clients and helps them gain some knowledge on the way. I very much recommend Sam if you are looking for someone fair to look at your coins, currency or precious metals!

I cant say enough kind things about Sam. He has been exceedingly kind, available, and honest in all aspects- he helped me find a bucket list coin and guided me through the process to find a good example. His communication is excellent and fun- I really enjoy hearing him and learning from his vast knowledge. A top notch guy and business!

Great to work with and goes the extra mile for the customer. Thanks for the biz Sam!

Sam and Logan are very helpful and knowledge about rare coins. They’ve been a great help to me! I would highly recommend them!

Dont let Sams age fool you! He is very knowledgeable and is well respected by the experts in the field. In addition Sam is enthusiastic about the hobby and truly strives to please his customers. From a fellow IN dealer, 5 STARS ALL DAY!

I highly recommend Sam Shafer..... he allowed me to observe, question, discuss during his valuation of my fathers coin collection. I was impressed by Sams expertise, his transparency, and his integrity. Thanks!

I’ve been doing business with Sam for a number of years now. Very honest and transparent. I would highly recommend Sam for any numismatic and bullion questions. Top notch guy!

Sam is very knowledgeable and helped me learn about my coins. In my opinion, I have met no better individual who is genuinely interested in helping out his customers. I highly reccomend Sam.

Sam is an extremely knowledgeable numistmatist and a man of high integrity. His experience and willingness to counsel me on my collection and direction have been invaluable. Without hesitation, I highly recommend Sam.

Sam is very kind and helpful. I definitely will be bringing him more of my business. Strongly recommend!

If you want an honest and hardworking coin dealer, then Sam is your man. I deal with hundreds of dealers across the country and Shafer Numismatics is one I never worry about when trading with.

Sam is very helpful and knowledgeable. I enjoyed our time and highly recommend him for any coin or paper money needs.

Knowledgeable friendly guys. Hope to do business again.

I found Mr Shafer to be honest, trustworthy and very professional with incredible knowledge. Highly recommended!

Sam was very knowledgeable and gave me a very fair offer on the coin I had to sell. Would definitely recommend him .

Called for an appointment and brought in a pile of old foreign coins I found in a home I was renovating. Met professional help from Sam and his partner analysing my coins and learned alot from them too. Highly recommended from my experience!!

This guy is awesome. Really easy to work with.

I’ve known Sam for several years now and he’s without a doubt one of the most honest individuals that a person can ever hope to meet.

Have done several great deals with Sam. Professional, knowledgeable, and friendly. Would highly recommend.

Top notch, easy to deal with and very professional!

I have worked with Sam for the last year and he has provided very valuable numismatic consultation. Sam has helped evaluate and provided a comprehensive strategy for conserving and maximizing the value of my collection. Sam assisted with preparing coin submissions to NGC and PCGS. I was able to submit thru Sam and take advantage of his dealer submission rates. This has saved me a considerable amount of money. I place a lot of confidence and trust in Sam and find him to be very forthright and honest. I would highly recommend!

I have been doing business with Sam for several years now. If you have a collection to sell and are looking for a knowledgeable, honest & reliable person to deal with, Sam is your man

He always seems to have what you’re looking for!

I’ve never done business with this dealer but he is active in promoting interest in the hobby and that says a lot about his ethics. Now I gotta pay him a visit.

Knowledgeable and fair

Sam is a very smart, fair and honest man!