Delicious sundaes malts and Ice cream. Also T-shirts are very high quality. I would definitely recommend going here.

Still as awesome as my childhood memories! I found myself in Fort Atkinson on a snowy Sunday in March. Its a rare event that Im in Fort Atkinson and even rarer that the lines for Frosty Freeze arent crazy long. Even at 4p, I waited a good 10 minutes in the drive thru. Nevertheless, my medium pineapple shake $3.00 (add banana $0.25) was delicious! The counter staff are very friendly and the prices are great. Note: they dont sell anything except sweet treats; but this is a hugely popular spot for amazing desserts.

Nice local ice cream shop and meeting place. Everyone locally knows it. They have many different options like dipped cones and banana splits. When it comes to ice cream flavors, they always have strawberry and vanilla, and have different flavors every week. They are closed during the winter. There is a drive-through, and you can eat on a bench or at a table. They also have fresh fruit

Hands down one of my favorite local ice cream stands! Great soft serve ice cream. Fast, friendly service. Family friendly prices. Plenty of outside seating. Loaded with personality! Even the cash registers are painted bright pink.

Super friendly staff. A wide array of different options and types of ice cream. I tried their root beer shake and raspberry shake which were both very good.They have some seating by the building, you can order by foot, and by going into the drive up window.Me and my girlfriend love to make bucket lists each summer and this summer we chose to do favorite ice cream shops, and this is one of those shops. We had such a good experience there, we will be back.Great day + Frostie Freeze = Even better day

The frozen treats here are made fresh and with care. They are super tasty and high quality. The customer service was also unexpectedly phenomenal. I wish I knew his name, but the young man working there today who took my 5 person order with an extra cone on the side was not only friendly and quick, but he had the entire order memorized. I was shocked and impressed. Plus, there are plenty of places to sit outside in the shade making this little frozen treat stand a gem in the bustling little city that is Fort Atkinson.

Got a coffee shake and it was amazing. It wasn’t overly liquify from the hot coffee it was really refreshing and still sweet. It’s so cool that they mesmerize orders.

Great soft serve in three flavors; chocolate, vanilla and flavor of the week. Efficient service and great prices. A fun place to relax with a treat and watch the world go by.

Always great, awesome, friendly service with a yes I can attitude! Whatever we order is always over the top of what to expect! Great prices too!!! My 85 yr old mother’s favorite summer stop!!

Flavors today were French Toast and Kulua. Yummy!!🍦😄

Been coming here since I was a kid- This place is amazing. Best banana splits in the world!

We wait for it to open and we go until they close for the season. Its an icon on Fort and its always worth the wait

Talk about a value for your money? This is the place to go for ice cream!

Great cash business, very fairly priced! Good shakes, soft serve ice cream, and classic icecream items.

Love this place! Excellent soft serve at great prices.

Always a treat to stop in to Frosty Freeze and it wont break the bank !

Tried the Mocha Freeze. Really good.

Best place around to get soft serve.

Always come when I come and visit and have never been disappointed with the service or anything I have ordered. Will definitely recommend to anyone.

Where the ice cream is always the best!

Some of the best ice cream around count on waiting in line for the drive through busy place but worth the wait

Yummy hot fudge sundae and fast service

It was pretty good and most people were practicing social distancing.

Good stuff

So much fun to stop for ice cream on our driving trip today. Great service and sweets.

Always a hit after playing at the park...or really at any time and for no reason :)Tried the Peach 🍑 Flavor of the day. Delicious!!

Its a great place to get strawberry soft serve ice creamm

Been loving this place for 40 years!

Delicious! I order the pineapple Sunday 😋

I always get a Butter scotch malt, my favorite!

Best ice cream stop in Fort Atkinson. Frostie Freeze is a little family owned ice cream shop and a classic spot for local families and through traffic. It has become a local favorite on hot summer days where you will sometimes find a line wrapping around the corner. The menu has classic selections from Rootbeer floats and malts to home made ice cream cones and sunday concoctions. You will not be disappointed with the decision to give this little gem a try!

We waited in line for twenty five minutes and only two cars in front of us!! Then snarky service and we had to tell two people four times our order and still got it wrong!!! Two out of four items wrong!!! Horrible!! And this is our third time there and third terrible experience!! And ice cream is not even good!! Never go back!!

Dont let this little place fool you it is the best ice cream place in town.

Cherished icon of summer for anyone that lives in the area. Great ice cream, excellent service, huge menu. Do not sleep on the real strawberry banana shake, candy freeze, or twinkle coat cone

Amazing service. Wish there was a way to keep this jewel shining all year round!

Great soft serve ice cream .great flavors.😋😋😋

Always pleasant people and enjoyable ice cream

Yeah yeah, Lets goooooooo - Dababy approves

Pistachio ice cream was amazing!

Best ice cream ever

Been a very nice place since I can remember. Been going here for 35+ years Awesome staff. Good frozen treats. Worth the wait in line

Honestly the ice cream treats arent anything to write home about, but theyre unbelievably affordable and its a Fort tradition. Whats not to love?

All ways good service and ice cream

Amazing ice cream, CANNOT BEAT THE PRICES! Must try!

This has always been my favorite ice cream!

Love the ice cream even though its always slow. Prices are now higher than Culvers.

A bit of a wait in line, but very nice workers and delicious treats!

Love me some twinkle cone. The dipped cones are great, too; my favorite is butterscotch. Great value. I stop here every time Im in the neighborhood.

Something so special about these small town ice cream shops. Ice cream is good, not spectacular, but the experience is so American

You have to go here!

Great stuff good prices

Ice cream is awesome and delicious

Amazing as per usual

Go very very sick on their icecrean

Good service and treats

Inexpensive, great ice cream

My ice cream cone was delicious

First of all, their ice cream tastes really good. I was also surprised by how reasonable the prices are.

Always a good treat! Love the different flavors they offer and that they have sizes small enough for my young kiddos. They support our school in Jefferson so its always nice supporting others :) The staff has always been friendly and helpful. Prices are AMAZING!!....no credit cards, so make sure to have cash. The shakes, sundaes and freezes are just so good. Such a fun place in the summer months.

Always busy, but nice staff. Good prices and can get puppy cones for .80 cents.

Good ice cream desserts and lots of choices. Be prepared for a long wait time, to order and get your items ordered. Its all made when you order it so it just takes longer.

Delicious and the best ice cream Ive had in a while. Their service is pretty fast and prices are incredibly cheap, especially during the coronavirus.

I love their blue moon ice cream !

Super bomb as usual!!

Best place in fort for icecream

Oh, come on - whats not to like?? Its Frostie Freeze! Great place to come with the Harley for some yummy treats.

A favorite attraction in Fort. We usually just get ice cream cones, but they have a variety of ice cream treats and drinks, not to mention tons of toppings or mix-ins. The prices are great -- a small cone is a dollar but its still plenty of ice cream for a person. Our family loves to walk there. On nice nights there can be a line, but chatting while we wait is part of the experience -- and you may see friends there too. There are several picnic tables and some benches (a few in the shade for the hot days). The flavor-of-the-day option is fun, too.

Great ice variety

Very busy but wait not bad .Product very good and reasonably priced

Delicious icecream. Great price. Window service or drive in. Due to covid seatting is inavailable.

Man they have some good ice cream! Really hits the spot

It was great 👍

Yum! Pretty much sums that up. We get the rainbow cone every time

Great ice cream!

We as a family love this place. Theres a drive thru or you can walk up to the window. So many tasty treats, new flavors, and the prices are so reasonable.

Ive been going here ever since I was young. I do think its a little overated but it does have tasty treats. Service has been a little less friendly lately.

Great place to grab old fashioned soft serve on a hot summer day. Prices are great and the staff is super friendly. If the parking situation were better and the lines werent so slow this would definitely be a 5-star review. You are best off parking in the street or the lot at Festival Foods across the street, otherwise you run the risk of being boxed in by the drive through line for 15+ minutes.

The best ice cream ever the double chocolate malt the best good service and I know because I have been to lots of places the best- one of the normal costumers when I lived back there

Best ice cream in town, wish it was open all year

Tasty ice cream ^-^ always a great place to stop for a scrumptious treat. They have a ton of unique toppings and flavors which make it a great place for everyone since they have something even the pickiest of eaters will enjoy. Be careful though, it is cash only, so be ready for that.

Great variety of ice cream options at a low price. My main gripe is they dont accept credit or debit cards. Feel like all places should do this in 2019

Best Summer Treats in the area!!!!!

The only reason this place is popular is because its the only place in town, yes prices are cheap, I feel like this is the most overrated place in Fort because its Frosties, I dont see what all the hype is about. Meh.

Wonderful ice cream

Love this place. Staff is extremely well-trained. Smells clean! Prices are very reasonable!

Good ice cream, and great staff. If you come during a hot summer day, or when most people just get off of work (5:30PM) then expect for them to be VERY busy. Be aware that they are a small business and only take cash (credit card companies charge a fixed percentage and have many rules).Ill be coming back.

Great ice cream love the twinkle cote

Prices are cheap, Ice cream is delicious. Only downfall is when it gets busy. It is a smaller operation. They take your order by memory and always have got it correct

This is a wonderful place to stop in the summer. The soft serve here is good and super inexpensive. Be prepared to wait in a line if you stop in on a hot summer night. But dont be discourage, line moves fast and it is worth it.

Great ice cream options and flavors. Great prices as well. We always come here for a ice cream treat.

Great stop for some quick ice cream with the kids. Lot of options and customizations available and the staff is super friendly. Parking is pretty limited and the drive thru has some blind corners which, in the short while I was there, caused multiple near-miss situations with kids playing in the lot area. There should be a fenced in area separate from the parking/driving areas for people to sit as opposed to picnic tables in the parking lot.

Although I cant get ice cream here anymore because Im diabetic my husband loves coming to get a milkshake a malt a cone or a concrete mixer Frosty Freeze they have a variety of treats and ice cream its mostly ran by high school students but they always do a good job of taking care of everybody and making sure that you dont wait too long to get your ice cream we always check on Facebook to see what the flavor of the day is I do recommend this place its a local place and the price is a lot cheaper than Dairy Queen in Baskin-Robbins and Stone Cold Creamery

Love this hometown ice cream shop. It is open seasonally and we always look forward to spring....to get our first bite of their flavor of the day.

Very fair price for the quality of ice cream. A pint of ice cream will cost you under $3.99.

They make the best Marshmallow shake I have ever had. I love marshmallow shakes and I have had plenty of them and this place makes that just perfect. If you are in the area, totally go get one.

Go here, not Janesville.

Best soft serve in the area and great service that is unmatched.

Great place for ice cream treats, freezes, shakes and malts, great prices. Tends to be very busy resulting in slow service. Root Beer malt is delicious.

Place is awesome. Good ice cream, and is super cheap. Lots of people working to expedite your order even when there busy. Only complaint is that they are seasonal.

Good ice cream treats but cash only.