Ive never had a bad sandwich or experience with Adrian and his staff!!! My birthday breakfast was spent here, outside, on a beautiful day. Goodfellas The Don is the best bagel 🥯 sandwich Ive ever had. The herb cream cheese, selection of meats, and I switch up between the waffle and cinnamon raisin bagel for a good yummy treat. Normally I get the Natalies notice but today I did OJ.

I used a service for delivery. The food was hot and fantastic. Can’t wait to try all the options. Amazing combinations but you can customize them to your liking.

So I’m not a person to comment however, This was the best fricken bagel 🥯I have EVER had in my life.If I could give 💯 🌟 stars I would!Was just a everything bagel toasted with cream cheese and turkey however it was perfectly toasted, cream cheese on both sides of the bagel, the steam was still rolling off 🤤🤤🤤Amazzzing! Everyone should go if u haven’t!Support Local!!!🤩🤩🤩👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

My first time here and I got The Don, a plain bagel with brown sugar cream cheese and a Columbe Latte. The Don was divine, simply put. The plain bagel was eaten before our 6 minute drive home. The price for everything was great. Highly recommend!

Absolutely incredible combinations and flavor. Best bagel place in town by far. Good location and staff are focused and professional.

2 things. Theres LOTS of fish on the Costa Nostra. Will will try and order half the lox and twice the onion next time. Like my crunch. That said I ate the extra lox separately. Its great.Second, not one thing for kids drinks. Coke or lemonade for breakfast? He can have orange juice anywhere. At least invest in chocolate syrup or hot chocolate mix.

Amazing sandwiches. Super friendly staff. Will definitely be going back.Daily 1-3 pm = $5 sandwiches, what a deal !

I finally found a place that does bagels right and really have some solid skills on how to assemble top grade ingredients into a piece of culinary art! The sandwiches are nothing short of perfection! So glad to have found them. A nice bit of pleasure during a dreary time.

Absolutely fire! Guys working there are really cool 😎

Very good food. Good service. Definitely a must try in Lansing

The food is great, but I was kinda annoyed that they dont make their own bagels. They are from Costco. Seems like the least they could do is make the bagels. With that aside the food is good

Stopped by to give them a try and everything that I wanted to order they were out of. I finally found something that they could make and it was good just not what I wanted. I will stop by again but not for a while.

If I could rate a negative number I certainly would!!! This was my second attempt at eating here BOTH experiences were AWFUL!!! The first time my online order THROUGH THEIR WEBSITE that was placed for pick up that took an additional 15 minutes after I got there and the only thing I ordered was the fries. Second attempt I placed an online order for delivery for fries and the SEC Parmesan Bagel but only got a bagel with cheese. When I attempted to call I was told to take it up with the delivery company that was used through THEIR website. I WILL NEVER recommend this place!! Food and service were both AWFUL!!!

Its only open for take out but its marked on Google for dine in. Plus theres no sign on the door saying to go to the window. Bagels are good though

Always excellent.Ive ordered from them multiple times and the food is always incredibly well prepared, uses great ingredients and tastes amazing.Highly recommend including one of the lucky waffles with your order, very tasty.

The breakfast bagels are amazing but the speakeasy menu is crazy good. Had to drive from detroit to try it. I recommend The Boss and The Irishman.

THE best thing about Lansing. Hands down. My mom has me bring GoodFellas back home to Kentucky, when I visit, and makes sure its our first stop when shes visiting. Great staff, great bagels, great service. Whats not to love?

The lucky is the literal best sandwich I’ve ever had in my life.

The best bagel shop in town hands down. Amazing selection, good vibes and great customer service.Don’t come to lansing without at least stopping by Goodfellas or you’ll regret it.

Love love love this place. I order from here way too much! There sandwiches are so delicious. Highly recommend this place!!!

The staff were awesome to work with for our catering order and the food was absolutely delicious! Thank you GoodFellas for making our event a success!

Absolutely Amazing LOX!DAMN GOOD BAGELS.

“The Boss” bagel is mouthwatering good and I’d recommend this place to anyone! Also has great service too!

Got a bagel sandwich and a coffee. Quick and tasty.

Great customer service! Ordered for delivery and was on time courteous and economical!

Theres a reason theres proly going to be a wait here ! THEIR BAGELS are awesome thanks guys 👍😎⚠️

Great customer service, creative sandwiches and exceptional ingredients and so good! Stopped in for the first time recently and this is now my new favorite spot. The Godfather was awesome! AJ helped with a large order of bagels and cream cheese that I picked up for a work event. Second to none!

Honestly the best bagels in Lansing. Their sandwiches are amazing and their customer service is even better. Theyre extremely accommodating, we had an issue with the last order we got from them through Grubb, so we reordered and I put a note in saying that it was a reorder because wed received the wrong item, ( still tasty, hubbys just allergic to tomatoes) I didnt want them to think the reorder was an accident, and they gave us waffle bites and a note apologizing on top of our order. It was so sweet, just like the waffle bites! Highly recommend everything they have, even the coffee! Love this place!

Pretty good food. Not the friendliest people.

First visit - excellent bagel, super friendly staff and good prices. Will try a sandwich next time.

Best bagel sandwiches in Lansing. Love the Goodfella!

My husband and I ordered 2 sandwiches online. It said theyd be ready in 28-38 minutes. When he arrived at the 40 min mark, they told him itd be 10 more minutes...He ended up waiting 1 hour and 30 minutes. They didnt even apologize for the excessive wait. Honestly, Id give 4 stars for the food, but such a poor customer experience is why I give 2 stars. I do get that places are understaffed and running lean, however, a quick Sorry for your wait, thank you goes a long way to earn repeat business. Really disappointed, as we were hoping this could be a regular place we go to.

The bagle sandwich was really good

Really good lox nice owner will come here again.

The bagel sandwiches are 5 stars. The time it takes to get that 5 star bagel sandwich is the issue. I’m happy to see how busy they are in the midst of the pandemic but when you order online and get a confirmation your order will be ready in 45 minutes, only to end up waiting for nearly 2 hours before it actually is, the process needs to be reassessed.

Quite literally the best bagel . If its store bought Im shocked! One bite and I could imagine myself sitting outside a little city deli, cup of coffee, and one of these creations. This place has the touch! Fresh ingredients, and flavor that will send your imagination into other worlds. Customer for life!

Food is decent but the fact that they quoted us 20-25 mins and it took a total of 40 mins for food then tells us “if we wanted 10-15 mins weekdays is the best”. No apology for the wait and didn’t value our time considering they started the sandwich 25 mins after ordered and asked us to pay before getting our food. Never going back

Was a good light breakfast. But filling & delicious

Great bagels and a great price to pick up a dozen to go. They freeze really well so its worth the trip!

First time in the restaurant today. Had just asked for a bagel with cream cheese but was informed that they were not taking orders anymore. They close at 3 and I was there around 12:30. The worker’s weren’t wearing gloves and ended up making my bagel after I pointed out they don’t close for so long. Got two coffees with the order and it was the worst coffees I’ve ever had, along with the worst bagel. Would love a refund because all that was $7.

Originally came here just to pick up someones doordash order, but I got hungry while the were preparing the order and the food just smelt so good that I went and placed an order for myself. Best idea I had that day. I ordered a garlic bagel with cream cheese and an Arnold palmer iced tea/lemonade. The bagel itself was phenomenal and the cream cheese tasted great as well.Super friendly staff and super amazing food. I highly reccomend coming here if you enjoy bagels and want to start trying bagel sandwich as well.

I’m struggling with this review. The bagels are super delicious. However, for a quick serve establishment, they need to do something about the wait times. I could have a 4 course meal for the time it takes them to kick out 2 bagels. Last time I waited nearly 45 minutes for 2 bagel sandwiches. More grills? More staff? I’m not sure but there has to be a better way.

Absolutely delicious. Will be back when Im in the area

The two greatest thing in life, never rat on your friends, and always keep your mouth Full off bagels.

Had the godfather bagel extra cream cheese and it was delicious

Took them 40 minutes to make 2 bagel sandwiches. Ordered online, was told when I arrived it would be 10 more minutes. 40 minutes later the food was finally ready.Would not recommend just based on service.

Wow! They turn the bagels into sandwiches. Cant wait to go back and try different ones! Authentic chorizo. FAT STACK of a sandwich. You can come here for a simple snack or fill up on FLAVOR. Guys working were super polite & busting out bagels like no ones business. Ya might even say theyre a couple of good fellas 😉

The workers refused to serve myself and the people I was with. Also, most were not wearing masks and an employee was eating in front of the counter and licking their fingers while over the prep station. Definitely not a sanitary place.

Ordered a bagel for.my son and he loved it! He asked if he could get one everyday lol!

My wife and I tried 2 different sandwiches and they were both outrageously good. The sandwiches are next level. I love this place.

Super duper fire breakfast sandwich with the bacon and chorizo and they’re definitely on to something with that side waffle. Short interaction with staff but all acknowledged me. Awesome spot.

Eating my millionth (conservative estimate) Goodfellas bagel rn and felt like it was time for a review. Tastiest ingredients, friendliest staff, and strongest integration of theme throughout the menu and shop. Also, it kind of feels like Goodfellas invented cutting a bagel sandwich in half? Their bagels are b e a u t i f u l—a social media dream! Final thoughts: fully endorse for your breakfast, lunch, and/or mid-afternoon snack needs.

Great food and people.

Update: been back a few times since that really long wait, food consistency is still really good. Wait times are still not great, maybe its related to online orders/technology issues. Id recommend calling as opposed to ordering onlineReally good sandwiches, and good price. But pretty slow service. But a recent experience is leaving me no choice but to give a a negative review. This past Sunday I put in an online order right at open, 9AM. I got a text confirmation saying my order will be ready between 10:am and 10:05 am. I get there around 9:55, order isnt ready yet, no big deal. At 10:05 Im told another ten mins, at 10:15 Im told another 10 mins. Im seeing other people come in placeing orders and getting their food before me. At 10:35 only a part of my order is complete and has been sitting for some time. I dont get my complete order (3 sandwiches) till after 11AM.

I had been wanting to try them out for a while; just had the Lucky and the Made Man...both so good youd paint a house for one.Also, the waffles were like the old country. Tremendous! Will be back to show loyalty and respect.

Great food and an excellent setup for socially-distant takeout. I was able to pick up my DoorDash order within seconds of approaching their walk-up window. Thanks again, we will be back!

Great customer service and the bagels were great. Loved the homeade cream cheese. Ill definitely return.

Absolutely one of the best. I used to work downtown and came here regularly. Now that I work in Diamondale, I still make a trip out once a week to pick up a sandwich from here. They are ALWAYS good. Just a awesome place to pick up a quick lunch thats fresh and always good!

Something to eat really quick

Fastest bagel Ive ever received and ate.

Waited for an hour in the rain watching other people get served first because I made the mistake of ordering online

So good. Im glad theres a great bagel shop around finally! Would definitely recommend the Don bagel, so much flavor and loaded. Cant wait to come back!

Tasty way to fuel your day

Best spot in town, hands down! Customer service is unmatched and Adrian is a very genuine man who cares about his community! Stop in and check it out!!

Awesome bagel shop in Lansing! Great location, great prices and even better bagels. This will definitely be a must stop every time we are in the area!

Need to order ahead of time . . atleast a day before or 30+ mins of the day of!. . i ended up leaving and never got my bagel. . .i waited over 35 min for a bagle and cream cheese....the owner wasnt wearing a mask as well as customers .. Very unprofessional behavior.. . have to give it to the two guys trying their hardest to keep up. . there were couple miss ups which caused orders to be delayed ..wish the owner would of helped. GO TO BANGOS!

Went to place an order. Website is down so I placed an order on doordash to pick up. Website, google and doordash said they’re open. Waited 30 mins to go pick up, multiple homeless people clustering by the door begging for money. Open sign on window. No one answering. I tried calling, no answer. Finally someone opened the window and said something about noon. I tried asking about my order.. and he closed the window. Bagel sandwiches are good however the experience was not.

I ordered Goodfellas for the first time through doordash. I got the fugazi bagel and it was to die for! My sandwich was here quickly and it was absolutely perfect! I will become a frequent here!

Placed my online order about 45 minutes ago Ive got hereThey said 5 minutes its been 10 and still no food.

Both of my bagels are the hardest, driest garbage bagel I’ve ever had. Seriously think they were made yesterday.

If you are looking for a place that has variety, essence, and amazing flavors look no further.

Just ordered breakfast on my way home from work, the Godfather and the Don. They were ON TOP of it and my order was ready by the time i showed up, I even showed up earlier than anticipated. The Godfather was AMAZING, the Don is next but if its even half as good as the Godfather, its still gonna be a million times better than McDonalds. Will be back tomorrow morning with the BF for breakfast it was so good!! So many options, not sure what imma try tomorrow yet...

I got The Hitman bagel sandwich and it was absolutely delicious. The ingredients are fresh, and the staff are pleasant and funny. 🙂 10/10 would recommend

Excellent food. Fun menu

Amazing bagel sandwiches! We definitely will be coming back again and I look forward to trying more selections on their menu :)

Great bagels, great sandwiches, and good coffee! The guys are always friendly! Love this place.

So so delicious!! Hits the spot in every way and makes your bagel sandwich dreams come true. The flavours of the Hitman Sandwich were complex with every bite, leaving you wanting more. The atmosphere was fun, clean, and the owners are so friendly. Get yourself here STAT!!

I cant say enough good things about this place so Ill let you go figure it out for yourself. Amazing. Tastes like rich sex.

The best bagel joint in town, you wont find better in the capital city.

The sandwiches are really delicioso. The guys that own the shop are cool. Coffee is pretty good, too.

Not just a regular bagel.. fresh ingredients, with all the fixings stacked high. Creative bagels with meats, cheeses, spices, peppers, veggies and just about anything else you can think of. My favorite so far is the Wiseguy.

Food was delicious, I would definitely recommend it

The Lucky waffle sandwich was delicious!

WOW! The best everything bagel in town! And the horseradish cream cheese KILLER!

Great atmosphere and great food! If you get an opportunity... try the waffles :)

Waited half an hour for two sandwiches and one of them was burnt! They never told me there would be a wait. Absolutely unacceptable. Will not go back.

Great service, great value, and great food!

Delicious breaky sammiches

This place is the bomb! one of the best breakfeast sandwiches you can get in Lansing!

Most awesome bagel sandwich in all of Lansing!

We had a lox and a egg and cheese bagel on everything. It was pricy, but really good.

Nate and Adrian are terrific, and the food is wonderful! Thinking of going somewhere else? Forget about it!

Great service with the best bagels in lansing! This is my new addiction!

My God this place is good

I used to be a Wiseguy...now Im feeling like the Don...on point everytime! Best lunch spot in Lansing

Delicious food, friendly service!

Great bagel sandwiches!

Best bagel sandwiches 😋

Sandwhich was perfect, super friendly service, great coffee. Only issue is the line was too long, I suggest you get there early.

Great Service, Great Food, Great Prices !!