Great store with really great and knowledgeable guys can’t put into words how great these guys are I recommend this place highly. If your looking to sell your records this would be the place to go. Been to a lot of record stores on the island none are as good as these guys. Keep up the good work gentlemen you’ll be seeing me again

Great shop. Not overly packed so its easy to search for the gems. Dont be afraid to ask questions. Owner had a first pressing of Jagged Little Pill in the back (open and Mint) he hadnt displayed yet. Picked it up for much less than it usually sells for, if you can even find one. Lots of variety, not over priced and no filler like most shops have. Lots of new stuff also. The day I went I saw a dozen unopened Record Day releases in the new arrival section.My new favorite record store

Has been among my favorite places on world since Seaford location many years ago Joe and Corey outstanding. Everything outstanding. Kind of like the line in Sgt Pepper but never out of style

One of my go to stores. I enjoy the owner and workers. Great selection of “new” used vinyl and $1 options. Have discovered a couple of gems in there. Prices are very good but I have spent a lot of money in this store. They have a large turnover so if you have been there in awhile, head back you will find some great stuff. Store is cluttered but that just means more stuff for you to nose through. Highly recommend.

This place used to be much better, prices went up, They have some decent used records, but chances are, you see something you like it’s probably in a pile covered with stuff with big, do not touch signs all over the store. Definitely thumbs down for that, why open the store if there’s tons of things there that aren’t for sale, price em. The owner, or workers are also glued to eBay and Discogs- looking for high prices. Not awful, but not what it was.

Awesome sauce of a treasure trove... As an urban dweller this is my favourite Island of Long haunt... If youre someone who appreciates reloving, reimagining and re homing vivacious vintage vinyl, CATastic CDs and bodacious books then you will not be disappointed... I promise!!!! Coolest place on the island. Fab. Helpful staff.... High vibe atmosphere.... Highly recommend...

Great record store with reasonable prices, cool down to earth staff

Its a great excape from the daily routine we have. Nothing is better than walking into a record store and feeling welcomed and not having to worry about anything else at the moment.

Picked up Da Capo by Love. nuf ced

Great place to sell used records. Fair prices paid. Friendly staff. Would recommend.

Best spot for vinyl digging in Long Island. The selection is epic and the vibe is so real. A very legit music store. They were also really helpful when I wanted to trade some old CDs for some records.

Great shop with very solid New Arrivals bins and stock. Nice selection of rare 7-inches and I even picked up a super clean, metal 45 case. Will definitely be back.

I just love this place. It is in Massapequa Park and it has been here for eons. Im friends for many years with a couple and they share my love of music. They pride themselves in having just about any record tape and CD that has ever been made. If they dot have it they will look it up and order it for you. Im waiting for an order since Saturday. The people and service are wonderful. I highly recommend it.

Great selection of vinyl both used & some still with factory seal. Bought about 8 used albums & all sound great. No skips & very clean. Prices are also very good. Recommend anyone who is into vinyl go to Infinity Records.

A must visit place for those who love to reminisce (for me) about,The BEST decade ever! Of course, the 1980s! A great place to relax and go through the thousands of albums and find the ones that you may have forgotten, is a HUGE treat for me!Plus, the staff is always nearby if I have any questions!

This is my all-time favorite go-to spot for records. Joe and Cory are awesome and helpful guys when it comes to music nostalgia. Plus, the prices are ALWAYS reasonable and theres TONS of gems and great deals to be found here. If youre into music, and you dont know about this place, then youre missing out. Big time.

Youll find what youre looking for in used & new vinyl here, then youll find things you want but didnt know about. From records to CDs, laser discs to music memorabilia & audio equipment, Infinity Records had it all.Ive bought many used records here and every one was in top shape, no scratches or pops, with the worst blemishes being found as jacket wear (which is totally understandable).The staff is very knowledgeable and friendly and will help a customer in any way possible.

Go. Great selections on just about everything.Staff there knows a great deal on music .A MUST Stop if you are on LI.

The best selection of Vintage Vinyl, CDs, Cassettes, and Vintage Stereo equipment etc on Long Island. Everything is priced fairly and the staff is knowledgeable, friendly, and honest. It doesnt get better than this.

No pressure.. Can spend the day there looking and relaxing. Great selections.

Vintage record store. Brought back a lot of old memories. Went there with my daughter who was amazed at the selection and the fact that there were so many records to choose from. Bought a vintage Queen compilation album. On our way home to give it a listen.

Greatest bunch of guys in the business that they are in fantastic place to sell your collectibles or to pick something up thats collectible never had a bad experience here :-)

Infinity Records holds the widest selection around in the vinyl market. From 8-track tapes to cds, turntables, records spanning every genre and size, as well as, vintage accessory items like clothing, gadgets, etc... Highly sought after pressings encased up on the walls had me feeling like I were in a vinyl museum.

Very nice business nice people.

I love record stores. These guys have a great selection

If you like to dig and be surprised by obscure records, Infinity is a classic. Hit the bargain and new arrival bins first and watch your stack grow.

Very cool place...found what I was looking for and then some!!

Great shop and I always find great collectibles at reasonable prices!!

Definitely worth the trip....Large selection of Vinyl and CDs.....some of which are heavily discounted....

Amazing place, really good prices, great selection. I was overwhelmed with it in a good way.

Nice selection, good finds at reasonable prices, shopper friendly atmosphere.

Great store, great selection, knowledgeable staff. Could spend hours browsing the bins.

Awesome place. So glad theyre around.

I wish i could go to this treasure trove weekly! Great selection, listening station and just a cool place!

Im reluctantly giving this a good review. I dont want to have to compete with others for good selection.....

Nice selection of Soundtrack lps my favorite and $1 lps. Staff is friendly and store is large enough to walk around in!

Awesome rare and hard to find goodies in electronicsguitars amplifiers and stereo.. Records and CDs Galore

Brought some stereo equipment to the store to sell. The staff member we dealt with (sorry I didnt get his name) was very helpful, and we left happy that we made a good deal.

Best used vinyl offering on Long Island

Fantastic place to find vintage vinyl

Was an ok visit,I didnt see too many cassettes of curiosity and the CD selection wasnt the best,I didnt see too many recognizable bands and albums,and I listen to a lot of different stuff,records were decent,but just not my cup of tea,still good enough to come to

Helpful staff and vast selection. Between the CDs and Vinyl selection you can spend all day here.

Knowledgeable. Have just about everything

Fun store to kill an hour in.

Really awesome place, staff is friendly and prices are reasonable!

Good selection, guys will talk to you about music.

Great guys very knowledgeable fair prices. Always seem to have something Im looking for.

Awesome place always a good find

The $2.76 record bin rocks. Go. You wont be sorry.

Cool place to buy & sell

Best record store on LI

Good selection and fair pricing

Great spot for records and accessories

Flamin Groovies shake some action!

This place rules. killer selection and unbelievable deals.

VINYL TREASURE GEMS HEAVEN

Nice place

Love it here