I loved this ice cream is organic and it is not too sweet. This reminded me colombia they have real ice crem.

It’s a good place for homemade ice cream. A lot of varieties. Open place, big parking lot, multiple windows to place an order, clean, quick service.

I love your icecream! I cant eat store bought ice cream because of the dairy/hormones/chemicals in the milk. I usually get sherbert. I got some dairy mint chocolate chip and vanilla ice cream cups from here and had no stomach issues. Ill definitely be coming back soon.

A great experience as usual. The best ice cream. So many great offerings to choose from.

The place is iconic. Parking is good. There is an additional parking lot behind the main building. 5-6 windows open at the busy time. Lines are pretty big on a good weather day and especially on the weekends. Ice cream is top quality. Very very rich. There are natural and sugar free choices too. No tables or seating. Not even in the lot. But there are things wood barriers setup the way it can be used for seating. Only 6 inches wide but good enough for 3-4 people to seat at a time. Pricing is a little on North side. For a medium cup you will be shelling $7.25 (at the time we visited). But the wait and somewhat inconvenience of no seating area is worth going for the really good product. A lot of variety and flavors. Kids sizes cups are also available. Such a Kool place with awesome customer service. Staff is very very patient and pleasant to work with. Go visit it!! You will understand the hype and you will not be disappointed.

I like Applegate Farms Ice cream its a fun place to come to with family and friend. Its also kid friendly and a cool place to visit. They have a huge selection of ice cream flavors and is super tasty. 5 stars all the way. (However it is not handicap friendly no place to sit for people that are handicapped, thats my only qualm about the place.)

Popular for good reason, though you might need to wait in line (we snuck in just at the right time, but immediately a large line formed behind us)! A wide variety of delicious ice cream flavors in a nice little farm environment.Be warned, the portions can be bigger than youre expecting! A waffle cone is, for instance, one size - gigantic! I personally would have gotten one of the smaller cups or sugar cones if I knew it was going to be that big - though there certainly are days where Im prepared for a giant cone like that. :9

Ive been coming here to get ice cream for years and they have never let me down. Always have great options and flavors available and service is very quick. I love any of their cheesecake flavored ice creams, but the Graham Central Station is also a favorite.

My favorite ice cream place ever! Some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had. One of my favorite workers is Paulo. He is so sweet to me and always gives me recommendations on the best flavors!

The ice cream is consistently good with probably close to 30 flavors. The only problem is that the lines on weekends are really long and its typical to wait 20 minutes or more before you get served. Some of the staff are friendly while others could care less about being there.

I am disappointed with the reviews. All the flavors I tasted werent anything special. The place is also very kitsch to try and attract tourists.

Decent local spot in Montclair for ice cream. Nice variety of flavors. The ice cream was very creamy. Nice place overall with parking. It can get very busy so plan ahead.

Ice Cream is hands down one of the best! I love the mint chocolate chip the most. Definitely a family thing to do.

They do have a lot of varieties. It is definitely a paradise for ice cream lovers. Over 20 flavors to choose from. We went as a group of 10 and hard a really hard time ordering our ice creams over the counter. The person helping us has to come back to us many times to confirm our order. They have to come up with a better ordering system. Online or give away a paper with all flavors in them for the customers to choose the flavors and toppings.

Very creamy tasty ice cream. My fave is rum and raisin. Get yours in a waffle cone.

I had a great time here! I’ve been coming here ever since I moved to Montclair 16 years ago! I was served by paulo who was so kind and very professional! Thank you for the delicious ice cream!!

Absolutely delicious ice cream and very pleasant service. I had their all natural Madagascar Vanilla & all natural Coffee. Nothing extra added and atill incredible. Definitely going here whenever I can!

Old-School walk-up Ice Cream Shoppe with an impressive selection of offerings. We like it!

I really want to like this place bc it’s close by my house but every time I finish a cup of ice cream I feel nauseous. At first, I thought it was just me but my daughter has gotten nauseous after eating there too.Pros: They have a good combo of flavors, the staff is nice, and the line moves quick.Cons: I feel pretty gross after eating it even if I like the flavor.

Best ice cream around! The packed parking lots says it all. The shop is well staffed and the lined move right along. The portions are generous and the variety of flavors is plentiful.

Best ice cream place in the area. The place gives you the feeling you are in a dairy farm getting freshly made ice cream. Taste is always great and the team behind the counter always friendly, patient and fast! I usually get the raspberry chocolate chip low fat yoghurt ice cream. Very smooth. Really good combo.

Not worth the expensive price they charge. 3 adults, 2 little kids, and the 2 adults bought cones....$40..taste wasnt worth it.

I love this place ! i was served by paulo and he was two professional, and went above and beyond to make sure i was happy with my order

I really liked the place! They have great variety of home made ice creams..I ordered Black raspberry and it was so delicious.. I cant wait to come back here...

My husband and I come here almost once a week for ice cream. Every time I always ask for extra sprinkles. Sometimes I get extra, sometimes I get the normal amount. TODAY, MY GUY MIKE WENT THE MILE. He’s a great employee and made my night! Thank you!

Just great ice cream and milkshakes.Wish theyd add dairy-free ice cream and shakes. After all, theyre an ice cream place now... no longer a dairy.

They said they had no milk to make milk shakes. I’m sure they just didn’t want to make two at 10:30. Didn’t help that only one out of the six employees even wanted to come to the counter to ask what we wanted. I won’t beg a place to take my money.

I love the creative hard ice cream flavors that they have here. Theyre always great.

While taste was decent $6.20 plus tax for 2 scoops! Come on thats insane! They dont even have the price listed for scoops.

It was a short visit on our way back from a family reunion. We all had icecream of different kinds, very tasty and enjoying. The service was good and and customers were there eating icecream. A real good Saturday evening freedom from the home, even for a short time. Applegate Farm is always a great place to stop, getting the pallet wet, while in the area!

Magnificent ice cream. The best I ever tasted. I will definitely be going back again.🥰🌹👍

Love the authentic flavor of their homemade ice creams. They have a ton of flavors that will not let u down. And the best part is, even tho its not an indoor ice cream shop, its still ice all year round with flavors that change with the seasons.

Wanted to really like this place, but I ordered a vanilla frozen yogurt and it was the worst frozen yogurt I ever had. The texture looked like kinetic sand. I ordered a cone and the girl told me she had to put it in a cup with a spoon and cone on top because she couldn’t get the frozen cone to stay on the cone! I thought ok maybe it will still taste good. It had the weirdest powder like imitation flavor disgusting. I had to throw it all away and for $4.60 I was upset. Overpriced and gross frozen yogurt. My husband and son enjoyed their ice cream- so maybe just stick to that ONLY!

Would be 5 stars but no prepackaged goods? (Unsure if true or lazy staff, one with which couple b4 me came back to complain she only gave her 1 scoop instead of normal 3).

Ice cream is the best.. many flavors... You can choose great variety and enjoy in a great place ..really is like a farm.. you can take a picture with a cow..

Ice cream is good, the service is terrible and they act as if they dont want to serve you.Not very good place to go.

Always a family favorite. Great ice cream and a plethora of flavors.

Great taste, serving the own dairy products, like milk shakes, ice cream since 1948. Orange Pinaapple its my favorite. Cant go wrong with it *****

Not a huge or original list of flavors, but every single one is amazing. The texture is similar to gelato, creamy and heavy. Best parking is in the back.

Always creamy and delicious. A treat that takes me back to my childhood visits here with family!

Employees are nice, service is fast & ice cream & shakes are really good.

Very nice ice cream, kind service. Even if you are not living close by, you should add this place to your must see list.

They have to manage their customers in a better fashion. The lines are pretty long, but that’s because the cashier is also the person making the ice cream. They should have people taking the orders and others making it.

I was expecting so much more considering all of the hype with this place. It was good, not great. Had the Toasted Almond flavor, I guess I was expecting more. Looks like they offer a lot of different movie nights and activities for a fun summer for kids.

Do u want to eat real ice cream? Than go to that place❤️and try real ice cream 🍨

They had a lot of flavors and you can mix them.

The Graham Central Station ice cream is to die for!

Great variety of homemade ice cream. I tried the cinnamon one and I liked it, but it wasnt my favorite, it tasted a little artificial and too soft. I definitely will come back to try other flavors because I think they have a very good ice cream, I would like to try the Dulce de Leche and hopefully I can give them 5 stars. It was my first time here, but I can recommend it.

Great ice cream and many flavors but the service is a bit slow.

Nice place, great place for ice cream., its little expensive for ice cream but definitely worth the trip. 1 negative a big negative, they dont have bathroom at all. AND your stuck nowhere. So please dont forget to use restroom before you go there!

Ice cream was good but i ordered online for a pick up…. they gave me a cup of ice cream and a empty cone…. made no sense!!

Best banana icecream. Raspberry flavor is super good too. And not pricey.. I wish they serve in better containers and give stronger spoons🙂 to eat the icecream

Delicious variety of amazing ice cream flavors. They have the best Pistachio Ive ever had. (shhhhh, order the cup, you get much more than a cone 😉👍😁)

Love this place. Fresh homemade ice cream and cider donuts! We plan to celebrate our little ones bday here next summer! Oktoberfest was great!

Have had the cherry Italian ice, chocolate chip ice cream, and cookie dough ice cream. All were very good. The kids work hard but the lines are still kind of slow. Prices are a little on the pricey side. A small is around $5, which is one scoop. It just seems like a lot when that is the price of pints quarts and half gallons of ice cream elsewhere.

Always loved it here, everyone else does too so lines can be long but always worth the wait!

People are extremely polite staff& clients.Something to be said for the EFFECTIVENESS of ice cream.

$6.20 for a small. Yikes! Good ice cream, have had better though. Cool spot - timeless look to it.

This establishment has been around for years and theres a good reason! The ice cream flavors they have is delicious!

Very good ice cream 🍦🍦, but lacking a few places to sit. It needs some benches. The prices are fair. The place is usually very busy.

Ice cream is good, lines are slow (understaffed or just slow), and food is expensive!

I took my wife and daughter to visit my hometown of Montclair and there was no way we was not stop at Applegate Farm.My childhood memories 🤗 kicked in.

Delicious homemade ice cream. Great anytime but especially on a hot summer day.

Worst icecream I’ve ever had… not trying to be dramatic but it tasted like sand paper and had chunks of ice in it! Artificial and powder tasting. Literally not creamy, can tell they do not use real milk. Don’t even bother with the crazy flavors- sea salt caramel had no caramel and tasted like chalk and the peanutbutter brownie tasted nothing like peanuts. The sprinkles were rock hard. Not to mention, the mint chip taste like tooth paste! I can’t see why anybody would go here, better off getting real icecream from biscoffs or van dyks. Very disappointed. I never have wasted a meal in my life and my family and legit had to throw the icecream a way because it was bad. Not to mention over priced….

One of THE local legends. Ive been going here since I was a kid. All of the flavors are good and quality has never waned over the years. Would choose this place over a Cold Stone or a Carvel 100% of the time

Great ice cream place, nicely managed and maintained. Many flavors! Lots of parking and lots of people too!

Awesome Applegate Farm and a great place to get delicious ice cream. The workers are so nice and friendly. My family and friends love the Applegate Farm.

I’m scratching my head trying to figure out why there are such long lines to go here for ice cream!?!? There was only 2 workers working tonight, and it was a long wait for ice cream that wasn’t even good! I sampled the strawberry cheesecake which wasn’t good. Then asked for a medium size cup with peanut butter fudge brownie and yellow cake batter ice cream. I also asked for one chocolate covered marshmallow and one dark chocolate coconut cluster to go. First off, the ice cream had a ton of tiny ice chips in it! The flavors weren’t that great either! The yellow cake batter did not taste like it at all! I think she gave me the wrong flavor! This is definitely NOT premium ice cream! Then, when I opened my bag of chocolates the girl did not put the chocolate covered marshmallow in my bag, but instead gave me a milk chocolate graham cracker! The chocolates were just ok not worth coming here for that either! With all the great dessert stops in the area why come here!

Always worth the trip there. The ice-cream so rich and creamy.

Not bad! Good place to get a couple of Sundays. Goth kids and Mobsters approved 👍🏼🤌🏼

Nice place 2 visit and have a icecream...

So yummy very rich specially the butter pecan is unbelievable! 😋😋😋

My childhood memory 😢😭💖. Very fresh ice cream !!

This is my first time going. Excellent ice cream... I had the maple walnut butter pecan combo thats pretty hard to beat !! two of my absolute favorites.

Cute icecream place. But super overpriced.

We go here more often than my cardiologist would like me to.

Homemade ice cream makes me happy! Ive been coming here for years. My cousins and I would come here when we were younger and everytime I visit it brings back memories. I love their pistachio ice cream and my husband loves the chocolate. The staff is great and Ive never had a bad experience.

Ive been going here since I was a toddler. The best ice cream around! Portion sizes are worth the cost! It was great to see them so busy again!

How could anyone pass this place by, on a hot and steamy summer day?! Great place to get your old fashion ice cream fix with the whole family!

Thank you for reaching out to me. I appreciate your time. I really look forward to visiting again. By far the best Ice Cream ever!

Today. At 90 something Farenheit. It was must stop point. Every age was enjoying a spoon of homemade icecream... from that grand mother with rolling walker to this 5 years old with icecream all over her hands....

Always good ice cream and great service fr the staff

Great place for ice cream on a hot day! I have been going there for over 25 years!

Nice & cool place with Awesome Ice Creams & Customer Service

There is a variety of flavors. The service was good. The place is always busy.

🍦Hasnt changed much since l was a adolescent, riding my bike there from Claremont Avenue. These two young ladies lived right behind Applegates. Always A Beautiful Day For Ice Cream!! 🍨

Great ice cream, brings back childhood memories. Used to stop there a lot when younger.

The ice cream is great but I asked for 4 flavors and it was 90% pistachio, and 2 other flavors and they forgot a flavor. Nitpick, but the spoons are also extremely flimsy

Everyone knows this ice cream is the real deal. Not much else to add except try to get something different each time you go, found some unexpectedly nice flavors by doing that.

Pistachio ice cream one of the best there...

My granddaughter loves this place!

The best ice cream hands down. Not the cheapest but its darn good.

Really delicious and creamy ice creams and sorbets are highly recommended. A must go place for ice cream lovers. They need to improve in their service.

A tradition of wonderful home made ice cream!

I found the ice cream to be overly sweet and cloying, not very milky, kind of chalky. Didnt care for the service, either.

Ice cream was delicious...signature milkshake was not made as well but it was probably a new employee making it.

Ice cream is good as always, lots of flavors. $8.00 for a waffle cone seems a bit high though.

The ice cream service is very good. Before Covid every week in the summer used to be movie night. Music, popcorn, magic shows, photo booth, hotdogs, and bring your own food.

Ice cream is very good, many flavors but expensive!!

Great place to go with the family. Delicious ice cream in flavors for everyone.