These guys are amazing!!! My tire blew out on the highway and they did everything they could to help me get a tow truck. When I finally got my car to them they got me in and out super fast. Everyone was very friendly! Thank you for helping me get back on the road! You guys are the best!!

Great Service! Reasonable Rates!

This place is awesome. First I had an oil change performed. They were quick and with a great price. Then I brought my car in for new brakes, intending on purchasing them, and they told me I dont need then. Sent me home

John H and John H are hands down the most professional, caring and informative team at this shop! Very fair pricing and no up selling at all! This is our new car mechanic shop for sure!

Had my oil changed here for first time. Service was great, was in and out quickly and tech didnt get grease all over my ride or forget to put screws back in my belly pan like some other places have in the past. Highly recommended.

Fabulous experience! My daughter was stranded on the side of the road because her front lip splitter had fallen down and was scraping road. She drove it slowly into this Tires Choice location. They took it off within 10 minutes and did not charge her! I am so thankful they saved the day for my daughter!

We call several times during our 2 hr wait. The service man informed us the a/c compressor will cost of $1200. We informed the manager not to fix it . We would like a oil change $50.00 and to change the Spark plugs. They said the total bill would be around $160.00 . We agreed on that price. $360.00 later. They just lost another customer .

The manager and employees were Very receptive and gave professional advise. They explained questions i had. The repair was good and I am very satisfied with the pricing.

These guys worked so hard to get us on the road again after a flat on our boat trailer. There were some outside problems that they managed in the best way. Good guys...Thank you.

Excellent, fast, polite service on a Sunday. Nice waiting area with free coffee. Thank you, John!

Polite and professional. Didnt force any extras on me, although I did ask for the filters to be changed. They made an appointment for me that fit my schedule and was in and out under an hour.

Scheduled my appointment on-line, very easy. Oil Change and Tire Rotation. Fast and efficient, friendly service!

Service was excellent. They were quick, efficient and kept within the timeline they promised which is always appreciated. Giovanni was great to work with and kept in touch with us as promised. Another major reason we will continue to do business with this location is we didnt feel pressured or that they were trying to up-sell us on anything. Its so nice to deal with honest folks and thats not always easy to find.

They take care of ALL YOUR NEEDS.... JOHN HUMBERGER ROCKS !!!!

Had a trailer tire blow out. Called and they had it for me next day. The whole in shop experience took less than 20 min. Highly recommend!

This shop is nothing less than amazing! Ive never met nicer, friendlier or more knowledgeable people anywhere. I was in and out very quickly, the owner treated me with respect and answered all of my questions. I highly recommend Tire Choice at 5785 Bayshore in North Ft. Myers! Im going back next week because the car is doing mysterious things again and I need an ACCURATE diagnosis and repair. Couldnt recommend them higher!

Very friendly associated and they take good care of your car only place I go to do my oil change..

Friendly atmosphere, great fast service great prices.

The most honest manger I ever metGreat place to take your car or truckThank you

This place didnt have time for me. I just wanted my tire patched but they were closing and couldnt do it. Gonna need tires soon but not gonna be here.

Im sorry to say I was very disappointed in the service and time I spent waiting for my tires to be done, 2 hours and 15 minutes to be exact. When I told the gentleman cashing me out that I was not pleased since he told me it would take about 25 minutes, he basically called me a liar and said he told me 45 minutes. I said no you didnt but even if it was 45 minutes which it wasnt it still took 2 hrs and 15 minutes. He once again basically called me a liar and said no it was only 1 hour. I said really, well I got here at 2:15 and its now 4:30 I think thats 2 hours and 15 minutes!! He just shook his head. Not sure i will be going back there for anything. So disappointed was hoping to find a reliable place to take my car.

Need an oil change and they got me in & out in a timely manner with very professional and courteous service from the staff

Very fast curteous service

I was not happy with their services messed up my plugs on my oil pan they didnt reset the oil for me I had to go back for that the two people working there all I did was argue backwards and forth about somebody elses vehicle wont go back

Great experience definitely will come again!!!

I thought I had a leak in my tire and stopped in to have it checked. This place is awesome! Everyone was very kind and helpful. Giovanni, the Manager, was excellent. Everything was good to go. Thank you, guys!

These guys know their stuff. They seem to be very honest.

Pleasant gentleman at the counter...pleased with this company...been here before, and they dont disappoint...

This is THE VERY BEST SERVICE I HAVEGOTTEN IN FLORIDA!!!!! Friendly..HONEST ..and GOT THE JOB DONE 👍👍👍👍❣️I Highly Recommend this Place ‼️‼️‼️

Service has degraded dramatically since they first opened. I wont go back again.

Very quick service!! Nice people!!

Im glad I found this tire store, they do all around general maintenance on your car at a fair price. And theyre always there for you!

They do know how to give great service and they are always nice and respectful for every customer that walks in there business. Its like one big family helping the community.

I showed up right before they closed with a screw in my tire. John was very nice and willing to fix my tire. They even stayed late late just to take care of their customer. Little did they know how much I appreciate them staying late. I’m new to the area and do not have any family here so it is a huge relief knowing they take care of their customers even when it’s time for them to go home!Thanks John!

The people are friendly and knowledgeable. I had gone to the dealership and they told me I needed to replace the tire, i was ready to do that here as yhey were saving me about $60 or $70 but when they checked the tire they said it could be repaired. This saved me over $300.

Fast tire change reasonable price and they are very knowledgeable

John was helpful, knowledgeable and quick to get job done. Good work energy!

Just cant say enough about the WONDERFUL service we receive each time we take our vehicles to Tire Choice. My wife and I are both disabled and John and his crew go to great lengths to make sure we are taken care of, professionally and personally. Recently we purchased new tires for our van and while there we told John we had a new hydraulic lift for my wheelchair (as the old one was toast) and wondered if they knew anyone that could install it. Without blinking John said, We can do that, and they proceeded to take the old one off and install the new one at a most reasonable cost. When the new ones construction wouldnt allow our hatchback to open, John and his crew took both lifts apart and reconfigured one lift from both that allowed the hatch to open. I cant tell you how IMPRESSED I was with their abilities but also their work ethic and professionalism. I will never go anywhere else for tires or service on our vehicles. Thanks John and staff and Tire Choice!

Close to home they were very knowledgeable and got the job done quickly Ill be back.

Excellent service from John and the guys - fixed my tire and got me back on the road safely. I will be back again for more service! Thank you!

I give them a 5 and didnt even need service! Pretty honest folks, highly recommended.

Great service - price matched my online price and gave me a great deal. True professionals! Highly recommended if you want it done right.

Brought my car here often when it was Rick Johnsons. I came in to have my car diagnosed. They let me know what was wrong, how much it would cost, and said they could have the part in later in the day. I left and decided to sell my car without fixing it and let them know I would return and pay for the diagnostics since I didnt end up repairing the vehicle.When I returned to the store, I can only assume it was one of the owners who ran the transaction. She kept poking fun at me that she should charge me twice for not coming back the same day and blah blah blah. While I figure it was a joke, there was no laughing by her, she didnt seem to give a care about what I was saying... Just not a good feeling. Even how she was treating the person who was buying tires next to me, money is money, Ill take whatever you have just sounds terrible.Be happy I actually returned and paid for a simple plug and play diagnostics. I wont return.

Jay Richardson the store manager is great and takes care of my needs every time I go to this shop. I have gotten brand new tires from this shop and oil changes done as well. Jay is knowledgeable and professional along with this shop as well. The service is pretty quick and you won’t be sitting in this place for hours waiting for your vehicle to get done. Fast service, professional, decent pricing as well.

Patrick and Brian are amazing; funny, professional and helped me a lot. I feel like I can trust them and plan on becoming a regular here. Their prices are affordable compared to other places in the area. Quick and thorough is how I would describe this place! Everyone should come here!

Great place..wonderful service..very fair prices!

It was a Saturday morning of course I had a tire that went bad & tired of used tires so I got a brand new one they got me in & a little wait then they called me said alls done . Fairly reasonable priced & the car drove like brand new. Thanks guys keep u the work & u all have a new customer.

I went in to get my car fixed after having major issues and they were great! They were very informative and helpful. Anna and the rest of the staff took great care of us!

ANNA AND GEORGE !! Amazing! I appreciate the help from them both!! Anna made us feel welcomed and had such an amazing bubbly personality. George fixed our flat in less than 20 minutes. Amazing service! Totally recommend to everyone! Had a great conversation with Anna she was really welcoming and such a hardworking employee!!!! In and out like nothing!! Hardworking both of them!

I love this place. Brian the store Manger is an honest and straight forward guy hit will take my car here anytime for tires or other maintenance work. They wont sell u anything you dont need. The tire prices are better than anywhere Ive checked. I wont take my car anywhere else again. The new manager John is amazing .

Just had a tire replaced there today. Quick, friendly and a great price. Happy customer!

I went to the store and Brian was super helpful in getting me the tires I needed and Patrick was also helpful with the warranty on said tires, due to the place being closed Brian and Patrick helped me apply for the store credit card so Id be able to get the tires fixed today and not have to wait for the warranty place to open. Im glad I came here. Brian was also very nice to my 5 yr old grandson, that meant more to me than everything else. I would recommend this place to anyone. Thanks guys!

Fast friendly customer service

John, the manager is awesome and accommodating

Pleasant experience! Richard met me at my car and was able to get my car back right away. The technicians were able to repair my tire and have me on my way quickly. I really appreciate the staff today 😍

Great service. Reasonable prices. What more could you want?

Great service - great price. Very professional- would definitely use them again.

We had an issue with our tire while on vacation. The staff at Tire Choice checked it out and we were told a nail did not puncture through. In addition, they did not charge for the inspection. Top notch quality and service! Back on the road in 15 minutes.

Jay is awesome. Extremely friendly, really cares and listens to issues you may be having with the vehicle. Took his time to explain everything they would be doing to my car. Quick turnaround for tires and oil change. Highly recommend this location!

Purchased tires from Walmart but they wouldn’t install them due to not being the factory size. Called up Tire Choice ( formally Rick Johnson) and John answered the phone politely. Arrived with my tires and they got right to work! The staff here is extremely nice and knowledgeable. John and Anna were super nice and made the visit a pleasure. I will for sure be coming back!

Wonderful service from Anna the receptionist and the crew! Heard what my problem was and they (team) are fixing it right away! Thank you for your time. I highly recommend it. Great people.

I called The Tire Choice because I had a flat tire and needed 2 new front tires. Anna answered the phone and had exactly the tires I needed, in stock. I put air in my flat tire and drove right to The Tire Choice. Anna was able to arrange for me to get new tires right then. Fast, friendly service and new tires is what I got.

Tire Choice is the best and so is Jay! We have decided to make this our family repair place from now on! Jay was helpful in answering all of our questions and helped us make the best choice for getting new tires. Jay even showed us photos of the breaks in our car to show us what we might need to repair next and be on the look out for. Great service and great people!

These guys were great. They walked me through my problem clearly and let me stay passed closing time while I waited for a tow truck. Very nice people and I would recommend to anyone in the area.

Had a low pressure alarm on a tire. I was a walk in no appointment and they took me in right away. Repair made, wheel re balanced an out the door in 1 hour.

Brought my car in for maintenance and was warmly greeted by Jay who promptly advised me about the great deals and offers they have available and took me through the check in process in a speedy and very efficient manner. All in all, the whole process was smooth and stress free from the beginning to end and the mechanics here today can be seen working really hard and efficiently from the moment I stepped in until I left. Thank you guys so much for taking care of my vehicle, you guys ROCK!

Fair prices, quick service. All around A+

Anna took great care of me and my vehicle. Got a fantastic deal on a set of new tires. Great experience will come back anytime I need something.

Service was great and fast. Prices were cheaper compared to others for tire quotes. I would definitely visit them again.

Excellent customer service!Anna was super friendly and explained everything that was needed before it was done. I would definitely recommend this location to my friends and family.

Went in for a quick oil change while on a lunch break. What a pleasant experience. Service was amazingly fast and efficient. The manager, Jay, was extremely knowledgeable, professional and polite. What a delightful experience for an oil change!! Thank you!

These guys are super nice and helpful. I was originally supposed to be there an hour and a half but they were finished before I even cracked my book open.Brian gave me an awesome tip about using a midgrade gas in both of my vehicles for better gas mileage and performance.Thanks guys 😄

Jay was excellent. Worked with me on getting me the best prices possible and had a genuine conversation while I waited! Very polite man, hope his hard work doesn’t go unnoticed! Appreciate you man! -Reith M

This was a great place to take your vehicles.NOT ANYMOREJay the manager has No clue about alignments or how your components work. The mechanics working on your vehicles are not much better. Aligned my truck twice still wont drive correctly. NO BAD PARTS AS PER THERE PEOPLE. But can not fix it. I will make it a point to tell as many people as possible dont go there ANYMORE. But they got paid up front before you drive your vehicle.

Great service. I got 4 brand new tires with an amazing deal. Jay is very friendly and has great hospitality. I was very satisfied with the service, and I will definitely come back when my car needs any maintenance. :)

Took a bit longer for someone to acknowledge me than I would have preferred. I was Very pleased with the oil change & safety inspection for the coupon price. I had my wipers done also.They were also very helpful to warn me that I needed 4 brake pads, 4 new rotors (can’t be turned?) and 4 new tires for the low, low cost of only $1,500.00+ 😱🤑🤬I am sure some of the NEW items can be had for less cost; such as used tires. The breaks I figured were coming due but I have had my SUV for 6 years. I have put 20k miles on it since I bought it. I have never had the rotors turned so where did they go?

Jay was very helpful and knowledgeable. I respect his dedication for making me feel safe out there on the road and I appreciate having a trustworthy shop to take my car to. I will definitely be returning for future services!

Wanted to have my oil changed and new tires put on and found out company had changed to new owners. I have had Chris as my tech for years & found out they just let him go because they would not honer his vacation pay. If this is how a company treats dedicated employees then I will take my business else where!

“The Tire Choice” (Previously Rick Johnson)Is by far the most unique shop I have brought my vehicles to be maintained...Amazing customer service with the new manager Jay whom convinced me that i did not need new breaks! For mine are still brand NEWW!!The guys in the shop Chad showed me exactly what was going on with my clink clink noise and fixed everything for an amazingly resonable price!Honest!Through!Integrity!

I like how they were informative on what I needed for my car and how I can maintain it. I especially like how the person who was helping me was very helpful in explaining why it was important for me to be more aware in handling the maintenance.

5785 bayshore location-Awesome price on my oil change! Fast & hassle free!! Thank you Anna for all of your help :)

I Had a great Experience. Prices are reasonable. They really go out of their way to help. Anna in the front is awesome. Very knowledgeable and excellent customer service.

Great management and so happy they are now The Tire Choice... Highly recommend trying them out. Same faces to take care of my car just new name on the building. The management and technicians go the extra mile to make sure everything is done professionally and in a timely manner.

Very fast and friendly! Amazing customer service. Extremely helpful. Will definitely come back. Anna was amazing! A+++

One of the tires I had recently purchased developed a leak around the stem. Went down and saw Anna and John. Got me in and out in record time. Work was covered under warranty. They clearly stand behind their work. Thank you.Mike C.

Recommended $900 worth of work

Walked in with an appointment for 10 am took my car early checked my alignment gave my a great discount on my discount tires and installed 4 new tires balanced new stems and all with friendly staff.

Very professional and courteous! They were very busy, but, still managed to squeeze in my car. Excellent prices and service! Ill definitely go back for all my automotive needs! I would recommend them to everybody I know.

Brought my brother there to get the tire pressure sensor on his daughters car before she take it to college. Ana took care of him right away after the dealer told him only the dealer could fix it. Great work!!

Very pleasant place..clean, efficient, and get reasonable. John was very nice to work with, good sense of humor! Thanks Tire Choice!

Awesome people at that tire choice!They honest and mechanics know what there doing. The guy John that works there is great and gives discounts!

Big thank you to Anna. She is very knowledgeable and doesnt try to sell you something you dont need. It was a pleasure to work with her. Tire Choice pricing is customer friendly.

Incredibly fast and efficient. Best tire rotation and oil change Ive had in years. Anna was very personable. 10/10 would recommend.

Go see my man Jay Rich here...best service in town. Brought my brand new 2019 Dodge Challenger to him because I trust him and his crew. Much love

My visit was extremely good. I scheduled the maintenance that my car is in need of. I was treated with respect and kindness. I know that the repairs that are needed will be done correctly. I was able to finance the service too!

4 Tires installed last month with amazing buy2 get 2 free deal!!! very satisfied, so I came back!! today got my oil change & transmission flush service for under $150!! Best deals in town!!!

Excellent tire shopping experience today with George and Brian! Very personal and professional. I will definitely be back and receive mend to friends. THANKS GUYS!

Anna and John were fantastic! Took my care of my issue immediately. Good pricing too. Would recommend.

I had a nail in my tire. I called this location - Brian and the crew got us in and out very quickly. While providing friendly customer service. (It would of been a 5 star review but the waiting area/bathroom were pretty dirty.)

Awesome service. Great price. Complete audit of vehicle. Very happy.