It was a unique type of store with everything pickles. If you enjoy the pickle aroma, you will definitely want to stop in for a look. I enjoyed browsing the selection of local goods. The proprietor was very friendly and brought out samples we could try before we committed to our purchase.

I love small businesses like this. The owner puts her heart and soul into these pickles. There is no pickle shop better than this. The pickles speak for them selves

Peter Piper picked a peck of pickled peppers. Or in this case Peter Piper picked everything that was pickled. From garlic too hot peppers, from bread and butter pickles to classic, everything here is pickled to perfection. Salad dressing, cotton candy, pretzels and other tasty tidbits all pickled for your pallet. I hear theyre bloody Mary mix cells very well also! The staff was friendly and it was a great visit!

Amazing place. Great variety and one of, if not the, best half sour pickle Ive ever eaten. Really great place.

Mom and pop shop with both tradutional pickle ans non traditional pickled items. I can say I will definitely go back and try more items but I will definitely go back for pickled eggs. I was skittish at first but I put through a few items and this was the hit. They even bagged the container to prevent chance of leaking. Definitely worth the trip or quick stop by if your at the nearby beach.

What an absolute gem! This place is wonderful. The minute we walked in it was clear I was in pickle heaven. The owner was warm and inviting and made us feel like we were at home. I bought pickled jalepeno and whiskey pickled pickles. Had a few tonight when we got home and they are amazing. My only regret is that I didn’t buy more!!!

Excellent atmosphere, delicious pickles, pickled beats at least what I tried., and also dont sleep on the pickled shrimp.

This spot is so incredible! I cant believe how creative and fun theyve gotten with pickles and they absolutely are crushing it on the original pickle flavors! We got some weird stuff that the kids geeked out over (like pickle popsicles) and the staff was so nice and friendly. Its definitely an experience!

Such a gem! The owner was super sweet amd we talked about new flavors to try! Will definitely have pickles shipped to us here in TN. Owner makes and cans them herself.

So many delicious options! I wanted to buy everything in the store. Narrowed it down to sweet & spicy pickles and pickled red onions with the most amazing blueberry muffin I’ve ever had that I grilled with butter - yum! Will be back soon for more.

All things pickle and more. Pickle barrel. Pickle cotton candy, cornbread, maple syrups. Delightful place. Very friendly staff

Very fun experience if youre a pickle lover!

The owner Lorraine is absolutely the best person. She doesnt allow anything on her shelves that she doesnt stand by. You will not be disappointed by her products. Shes even gotten my now 6 year old to try more foods since she was about 3 when we first started trying her products.

I love stopping anytime Im in the area. The staff is always so friendly and everything Ive tried is delicious. If youre a pickle fan you definitely need to stop here! I love the sour pickles and pickled brussels sprout the best.

Friendly and welcoming atmosphere, unique store, amazing employees and great pickles too.

Walked into a somewhat stuffy environment full of pickles and pickled vegetables, etc... what would you expect from a place with such a name as The Pretentious Pickle?!! Well...I will be going here every time I visit Plymouth. Their pickled beets and pickled eggs are incredible, that is on top of all of the actual pickles! I need to try them all!

We absolutely loved this store. Super cute in a wonderful area! Will be visiting eveytime we go back to Plymouth!

Hidden gem, great owners and products. Love the corn bread

Delicious pickles! I bought a jar for myself + a bunch for gifts but I had to go back the next day because I ate my whole jar in a day 😭😂. I’ve tried the sweet + spicy and the sweet as Sophia so far + they’re dangerously yummy. Lorraine was super friendly + helpful + there’s lots of other local goodies as well. Def worth a trip!

Best pickles i’ve ever had, and the nicest owner you will ever meet

Everything they sell is top notch and worth every penny.

Pleasant atmosphere with even better people. If you walking by it’s a Must. Stop. In.

Great place if you love pickles! They have an old time pickle barrel too!

A broad and interesting range of pickles, pickle flavoured foods and locally made stuff. Nice location right by the harbour.

Owner is unbelievably nice and pickes are great

What a great little local store Great items to choose from and super friendly service. Owner is just wonderful

The was one girthy, juicy pickle. High praise!

What do you call a pickle you buy at a great price? A sweet dill! I just stopped by The Pretentious Pickle on Friday and picked up garlic dill pickles and bread and butter pickles. Two days later and they are almost gone! If you like pickles, youll love Lorraines!

You must stop in. Pickled onions are great on sandwiches 🥪

I have had her beets, Brussels sprouts, and asparagus. They are delicious!!She sent them to me in San Diego after I had tried them when visiting my son in Plymouth.I highly recommend them. Great job and I wish you well.

Greatest local pickles. Pickled veggies and various pickles in gift sizes also loose large pickles. If you are a pickle person this is a great little local gem to check out! Family owned and run and it shows in the love they put in!

In the best way possible, going into this shop is always a jarring experience. The staff is extremely friendly and there are usually a few deals going on that’ll help save you some money. As a pickler myself, I don’t know how they do their magic, but their Sweet Crunchy Onion pickles are what I strive for with every harvest. What really seals the dill though? The free samples, relish it all in, going into this store is quite an experience. It’s hard to walk out with less than 4 jars of goodies, although I never regret balling out in here. Fun to watch them go from the farmers markets to owning their own store. Keep on rocking on Pretentious Pickle

Love the pretentious pickle! The owners are so welcoming and friendly. The pickles are delicious. Excellent variety!

Great place. Sample everything before you purchase. The owner is incredibly friendly, helpful and honest. All picked items are pickled by the owner. I wanted pickled cauliflower, she said she had checked it this morning and it wasnt ready. She will have 40 jars on Wednesday! Next time your in Plymouth, swing by the waterfront and check it out. She is across from East Bay Grille, last business before it becomes residential.

What an awesome little shop! The pickle selection was phenomenal. Try the Whiskey pickle for sure.

Passed The Pretentious Pickle Co. On a stroll with the family through Plymouth. We are so glad we stopped in. This beautiful store is incredible. The staff was wonderful and knowledgeable. There are samples of everything. We will be back every time we visit Plymouth, we highly recommend you stop in as well.

Perfect in every way highly recommended everything is delicious I will be back again very soon!!!

Great as always..brought a friend with me today !

Great products and very friendly service. Can’t wait to try more .

Garlic Dill Pickles...Rule

😀

You must check it out