First time here! I have to say, the employees are so friendly and they let me know right away that I could try any of the flavors first before ordering. I didn’t feel pressured to hurry up and make a decision, which is always a good thing. The sweet gal who greeted me first let me know about all of their different sections- for example, this shop has it all- gelato, ice cream, and also vegan, nut-free and gluten free ice cream selections! How many ice cream shops around offer such a vast array of choices, flavors, and dietary specialties? They also have ice cream cakes and of course soda floats! The store is clean, well lit, and filled with bright colors! They are also eco-conscious and you can choose to have your receipt emailed or texted to you. Every $5 (I think that’s the amount) you spend earns you 3 stars and although I don’t recall what enough stars will get you, its guaranteed to be something sweet!! I ordered a medium cookies and cream sundae with walnuts and hot fudge. Unfortunately they were out of hot fudge but they had chocolate syrup. The other nice employee helped with with my order of a pint of ice cream to take home. ***I have one friendly suggestion based on an on observation I made: I think the temperature of the freezers may need to be turned down a bit because some of the ice cream buckets appeared to be melting and very soft at the top. I had to put my ice cream in my freezer at home for awhile before the ice cream was firm enough to eat.*** Once I enjoyed my sundae a few hours later, I found the flavor and consistency to be creamy and delicious- like true ice cream from an old fashioned store. Hopefully they will be able to turn the temp down and stock up on that hot fudge- those things could be deal breakers for some folks. Otherwise, a very nice place! I will be back to try some gelato!

Super delicious, fresh and best homemade gellato. Tried their chocolate rasberry and blueberry basil. The later one is to die for...what an amazing combination! Very friendly attendants too. Must visit!

Ice cream, Italian ice, soft serve and Gelato.

Gelati by mike is the best ice cream in the area! Everything about this place is amazing starting with the owner. Kevin is so friendly and always wants to make sure you’re enjoying your ice cream. The assortment of flavors is unbelievable— it is sure to satisfy any craving. This will be your new favorite ice cream spot!

I ordered curbside pick up. Upon arrival I called the number listed in the confirmation text. No answer! Then I texted that I had arrived and indicated where I was parked. No reply. Finally went in and picked it up myself. Great product, but now I know to not ask for curbside pickup. Would have given 5 stars otherwise.

I love indulging myself with the amazing variety of gelati and ice creams Kevin has on his repertoire!!This is my go-to place for the best italian style gelato!!

Best Gelato and milkshakes in NJ, friendly owner and great customer service. Highly recommend.

They sell Italian gelato along with ice cream & ices. A great variety of different flavors made fresh daily right on the premises. There are two other locations also in Caldwell & Montclair. The owner is Filippino so they even sell purple ube ice cream. If you like gelato/ice cream give this place a try. The kids will love it...

Kevin, the owner is super friendly! His gelatos are delicious. The blueberry basil is one of the best! The amaretto, pistachio, Nutella, espresso are delicious! Go in and sample any flavor

I don’t go to any other ice cream place than to this one. I make the thirty minute drive because it’s consistent and the guys working there are hard working and actually love their job.

The gelato is great but what kind of Italian ice cream place doesn’t have Italian ice. I got a Junior cup for $5.00, which to me is pretty high. I also had a coupon which they refused to honor even though the expiration date was a week later. Very disappointed.

Great Gelato that carries on the tradition of the other locations in Passaic County.

Excellent customer service! Excellent gelato!

Weve been coming here for since they opened and have never been disappointed. Highly recommend since they make their own gelato and use only the finest ingredients. Gelati by Mike☆☆☆☆☆ 🍨

They have great service! Their flavors are amazing and they are always the same great quality! They provide many options for all! This is my favorite icecream store now!

Amazing gelato and ice cream! Super fun atmosphere in the shop with amazing products and amazing people. You won’t regret stopping in for a sweet treat!

I love this place!! AMAZING ice cream and gelato, the sorbets are so refreshing. I personally love the espresso chip gelato SO GOOD. Thank god there is a new and great ice cream place in Randolph people can hang at.

Best gelato ive ever had. Try the cookie monster its life changing. The owners a cool dude too 👍🏼

The gelato is very good. Friendly staff.

Im really picky, but this ice cream is yummy and local. The staff is always warm and welcoming.

We all had gelato - flavors were good but we all agreed for the size of the portions the prices seemed high - we will not be going back

Finally! The ice cream Ive been waiting for. The gelato is amazing and the regular ice cream is so creamy and tasty. Yum!

Delicious gelato and ice cream. The Nutella gelato is so delicious...as well as the marshmallow.

Very good Gelato! I got the blueberry basil Gelato, it was a little sweet for my taste buds but it went very well with the Rocher Gelato! I will definitely go again. The guy who waited on us was very nice and he let us try samples of different kinds.

The gelato was creamy and delicious. Tried the chocolate raspberry, expresso, and Ube. They were all amazing!

Various fresh and delicious flavors of ice cream, gelatto and sorbetto. I had chocolate, lime and blood orange sorbetto. They were each great. My wife had watermelon and blood orange sorbetto and blueberry basil gelatto. All very good. Prices are very reasonable and the scoop sizes are large. What a great addition to town.

BLUEBERRY BASIL IS THE BEST AND SO IS THE STAFF

By far the best Ive ever had!!!

Love the cannoli gelato!

This was great ice cream.

Great ice cream selection and friendly staff

The place has been closed for a while

Great Ice Cream and Gelato!!

They have amazing treats

Really good gelato

Not enjoyable at all, the prices are outrageous for ice cream that they are calling Gelotti.

Awesome ice cream

Creamy iceceam

Best ice cream!!

Delicious!!!